One day into actor Jussie Smollett’s very odd story, I knew the narrative was in trouble — with black people. Skepticism about the particulars of the assault in the comment boxes at TMZ and at black pop culture sites was rampant. “You know that [blank] is making it up,” was the typical response followed by “LOL!”

Some black folks really do have a finely-tuned Spidey sense when it comes to claims of racial assault and violence. The pre-O.J. Simpson power of black celebrity is over in the era of black Twitter, irreverent podcasters and Bill Cosby sitting in prison.

To paraphrase late night talk show host Trevor Noah from earlier this week, Jussie Smollett’s story was always fishy. “That’s right,” Mr. Noah said long before SNL or any of his fellow late-night comedians were willing to wade into the controversy, “the police now believe Smollett staged his own attack — which would be insane, but you have to admit, there’s a certain part of the story that was always a little weird.

“Like, who are the MAGA supporters who hate gay people, who hate black people, but also happen to watch ‘Empire’? Like, I’ve heard of hate-watching, but that [expletive] would be next-level. That’s like a member of the Klan buying tickets to ‘Fiddler on the Roof.’ “

Advertise with us

The fact that Jussie Smollett’s story unfolded in the middle of the R. Kelly controversy — also in Chicago — where celebrity privilege has insulated a popular singer suspected of the sexual exploitation of young girls for decades — is the worst possible timing for the “Empire” actor.

On Thursday morning, Mr. Smollett was arrested and charged with a felony for filing a false police report and claiming he was the victim of a hate crime.

Mr. Smollett claimed he was attacked by two white men at 2 a.m. who shouted racial and homophobic slurs, sprayed him with a bleach-like substance and tied a rope around his neck while boasting, “This is MAGA country.”

Somehow, Mr. Smollett got a deluxe package of racist and homophobic violence when just one of these terrible things would’ve been enough. The lack of corroborating video or footage on the dozens of surveillance cameras in the area where the assault allegedly took place was immediately suspicious. His reluctance to hand over his phone to investigators — and the failure of his alleged assailants to take it from him — also raised eyebrows. The oddest detail of all was the fact Mr. Smollett drove himself to the hospital without ever removing the rope from around his neck.

Meanwhile, the only suspects who were caught on surveillance cameras that night happened to be two Nigerian brothers with ties to the actor. When they were arrested and interrogated about their part in the drama, the young men implicated Mr. Smollett as the plot’s mastermind and claimed they were paid nearly $4,000 for their trouble.

Advertise with us

Evidence backing the brothers’ version of the story was found in their apartment, leading the authorities to conclude that Mr. Smollett staged his own hate crime.

Mr. Smollett has a lot of explaining to do and a lot of mockery to endure. He has been charged with a felony and has damaged his reputation in ways that won’t be fully quantified for years. Unless he’s truly the victim of the most elaborate frame job in the annals of celebrity crime, at some point he’ll have to “own up” to what he did and explain why he would risk everything he’s worked so hard for just so he could cruise to celebrity victim status on a red carpet.

Some fear that Mr. Smollett’s “hate crime” will bring suspicion on future LGBTQ and minority complaints about assaults. How likely is that given the ubiquity of smartphones? In fact, public opinion now expects a video to accompany every allegation, or it will be suspect if none of the other evidence checks out.

Yes, the Chicago police have a shaky reputation thanks to decades of framing, brutalizing and killing black and gay people, but there’s no evidence that Jussie Smollett is being railroaded by an intolerant justice system out to protect Trump supporters. This looks like a case of a troubled young star of a weekly soap opera trying his hand at crafting what he hoped would be a compelling anti-Trump storyline.

Alas, like a lot of actors who would rather write or direct, he’s proven to be especially bad at basic storytelling. His narrative never made sense and it was bound to fall apart because of its lack of internal — or external — logic.

Advertise with us

In a statement released by his lawyers on Thursday, Mr. Smollett maintained his innocence and denied having orchestrated his own attack. This is not a good sign that this self-imposed melodrama will be over anytime soon. The celebrity support he generated early on will quickly disappear, leaving only his most credulous fans and family in his corner.

Getting caught in a lie that has led to felony charges and mockery from the right wing and contempt from allies on the left isn’t the worst thing that could’ve happened to Jussie Smollett.

The worst thing would’ve been a “Good Samaritan” with a permit for a concealed handgun stumbling on the fake street tussle and shooting one or both of the actor’s accomplices.

Imagine if a random cop on night patrol had come upon that scene and intervened in the same way. All hell would’ve broken loose. Mr. Smollett deserves to be embarrassed by all of this, but at least he doesn’t have blood on his hands or his conscience. Ironically, the “bad actor” in all of this is the one who gets paid for acting and who should’ve recognized a terrible script when he concocted it.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.