Sen. Kamala Har­ris, D-Calif., is look­ing pretty for­mi­da­ble to Re­pub­li­cans these days. You can tell they’re ner­vous about her be­cause of the half dozen or so corny memes float­ing around about her back­ground — none of them true.

In a prop­erly func­tion­ing de­moc­racy, a meme wouldn’t be much of any­thing other than some­thing to be skep­ti­cal about, but our short­ened at­ten­tion spans mean our pol­i­tics are in­creas­ingly de­fined by these ex­pertly pack­aged lies. Un­for­tu­nately, if enough peo­ple be­lieve them, it doesn’t mat­ter how ri­dic­u­lous they are.

Ask for­mer Vice Pres­i­dent Al Gore. His 2000 pres­i­den­tial bid was hob­bled by a meme that, aided by main­stream me­dia le­git­i­macy pur­posely mis­con­strued his Senate record and turned him into a self-ag­gran­diz­ing “father of the in­ter­net.”

For Ms. Har­ris, the memes have taken a fa­mil­iar path — birther­ism and the al­leged in­au­then­tic­ity of her ra­cial back­ground. Ms. Har­ris was born in Berke­ley, Cal­i­f., in 1964 to a Tamil In­dian mother and Ja­mai­can father.

Advertise with us

The fe­ver swamps of the hard-right have al­ready con­cocted a con­sti­tu­tional cri­sis of what is a fairly straightfor­ward or­i­gin story by in­sist­ing that be­cause her par­ents were “for­eign­ers” (i.e., in­ter­na­tional stu­dents), she’s not a real Amer­i­can. Ap­par­ently, be­ing born in Berke­ley, Cal­i­f., only gets you so far be­fore you have to show some ad­di­tional pa­pers — like Barack Obama should’ve done.

Like Mr. Obama, Ms. Har­ris spent some cru­cial years liv­ing abroad af­ter her par­ents di­vorced. She at­tended high school in Mon­treal, Que­bec, where her mother taught at McGill Univer­sity. At no point did she be­come a Ca­na­dian cit­i­zen, but try tell­ing that to folks who sus­pect yet an­other dark con­spir­acy from a first term sen­a­tor with a sus­pi­cious re­li­gious ped­i­gree (Hindu and Bap­tist) and a multi-ra­cial back­ground.

Ms. Har­ris at­tended Howard Univer­sity, the most fa­mous of the HBCUs in the coun­try, where she as­serted her black­ness from the be­gin­ning.

Still, some talk­ing heads — even at “lib­eral” MSNBC — have had the te­mer­ity to ask whether she’s been “ac­cepted” by the black com­mu­nity as “one of its own.” These clue­less opin­ion-mon­gers don’t seem to re­al­ize that be­ing black isn’t like be­ing sub­ject to a panel de­ter­min­ing early ad­mis­sions to a uni­ver­sity.

People for­get that Mr. Obama was also dog­ged by per­sis­tent ques­tions of whether he was “black enough” a year be­fore he be­came pres­i­dent. Some blacks hos­tile to his can­di­dacy and more than a few white com­men­tators had very fixed no­tions of what con­sti­tuted “real black­ness” back in 2007 and 2008. Be­ing from Hawaii wasn’t one of them.

Advertise with us

Ms. Har­ris is go­ing through a ver­sion of that to­day. When she was re­cently asked on a pop­u­lar hip-hop morn­ing talk pro­gram whether she’d ever smoked weed, she ad­mit­ted that she not only smoked ganja, but had in­haled, jok­ing that half her fam­ily was Ja­mai­can.

Be­cause she was in­ter­viewed by two hosts, there was a lot of laugh­ter and crosstalk in the stu­dio. While still in the mid­dle of dis­cuss­ing her weed con­sump­tion, she was also asked about the kind of hip-hop she lis­tened to back in the day.

Con­scious, no doubt, of the im­por­tance of the Cal­i­for­nia pri­mary to her elec­toral plans, she vol­un­teered Snoop and Tupac as her fa­vor­ites. She was not in­di­cat­ing that she lis­tened to ei­ther rap­per while she was in col­lege smok­ing grass be­cause nei­ther one of them was re­cord­ing in the early and mid-80s. They en­tered the hip-hop scene in the ’90s.

In the early ’80s, there were no no­ta­ble West Coast rap­pers Ms. Har­ris could’ve repped with­out get­ting dragged for it. Of course, Fox News and other right-wing sources made it seem as if she was claim­ing to have lis­tened to Snoop and Tupac songs that didn’t ex­ist when she was at Howard when she was clearly an­swer­ing two dif­fer­ent ques­tions. This is what hap­pens when Fox re­ports what black peo­ple say.

Con­se­quently, Ms. Har­ris is be­ing knocked for smok­ing weed and pan­der­ing for street cred to come across as more “au­then­ti­cally black.” For the in­at­ten­tive who are only skim­ming head­lines at this point, it’s a seed of doubt that could flower into out­right skep­ti­cism about her char­ac­ter later.

Advertise with us

Cer­tainly, there’s enough in Kamala Har­ris’ record as Cal­i­for­nia’s At­tor­ney Gen­eral and her cur­rent stint as a first-term sen­a­tor to le­git­i­mately ques­tion if she’s as pro­gres­sive as she in­di­cates. Many young, black Dem­o­crats hold her record as a law-and-or­der DA against her.

A fair read­ing of Ms. Har­ris’ record in­di­cates she was, at times, a cau­tious pol who some­times failed to fight for in­ter­ests she loudly cham­pi­ons to­day. At the very least, she’s a work in prog­ress who has demon­strated an abil­ity to lis­ten and learn from her con­stit­u­ents. She adapts with the times and is smart enough to ad­mit it.

In the mean­time, the at­tempt to make Kamala Har­ris an ex­otic and thor­oughly alien “other” like what was done to Mr. Obama isn’t go­ing to work. She’s too rooted in black com­mu­ni­ties from D.C. to the Bay area to be easy pick­ings over cul­tural is­sues. The stu­pid memes un­leashed so far aren’t go­ing to work. Be­cause of this, she is likely to be one of the last Dem­o­crats stand­ing in 2020.

Tony Nor­man: tnor­man@post-ga­zette.com or 42-263-1631.