As metaphors go, the confrontation that unfolded in the shadow of the Lincoln Memorial last Friday perfectly encapsulates the ragtag nature of our messy, divisive, dispiriting and thoroughly humiliating American reality in 2019.
There were Catholic school boys from Kentucky wearing red MAGA hats and whooping it up with school fight songs. One of their members, a high school junior, stood before a Native American elder who chanted a song of loss and remembrance while beating a hand drum. The man was at the National Mall to participate in an Indigenous Peoples March.
It looked like the echo of some immeasurably tragic confrontation that we know took place more than a century ago between the ancestors of some of the boys and the original occupants of this land. The only thing missing was a single tear sliding down the protestor’s face.
Standing to the side were members of a little-known sect known as the Hebrew Israelites, a black separatist group that has nothing to do with the Nation of Islam, as the parents of some of the boys erroneously alleged. Their beliefs are based loosely on Christianity and Judaism.
Because everything that happens in America migrates to social media within seconds, the staring contest between the smirking student and the Vietnam veteran went viral instantly.
Within hours, it generated worldwide condemnation of the boys and prompted officials at their school to rebuke them.
The boys had traveled to D.C. to participate in a pro-life rally. The ubiquity of their pro-Trump hats and the fact that they were overwhelmingly white, male and loud, made them look like poster boys for Gillette’s toxic masculinity ads. Oh, and all of this happened at the Lincoln Memorial at the beginning of the long Martin Luther King holiday weekend with a nearly month-long government shutdown providing the background noise to our national dysfunction.
After a wave of condemnation based on the first video, another wave of videos and interviews with the central characters provided missing context. This additional information demolished the viability of the initial story, with its lopsided morality of racial persecution, and broadened the cast of who was responsible.
In videos that spanned more than an hour, the Hebrew Israelites, also known as Black Israelites, can be seen taunting a small group of boys with homophobic jabs and crude racial put-downs about their whiteness.
When the number of school boys grew so large that they no longer felt threatened, they returned fire, which only increased the ferocity of the Israelites’ derision. Most of the cursing and swearing came from them.
The tribal elder, who feared a confrontation between the black men and white school boys, waded into a crowd of Covington Catholic High School students from Kentucky to drum and sing a Native song in an attempt to defuse the tension. The boys responded by imitating him in a way that was interpreted widely as disrespectful. The fact that some did “Tomahawk chops” reinforced the impression.
Meanwhile, Nick Sandmann, the 11th-grader who locked eyes with Nathan Phillips of the Omaha Nation, claimed that what appeared to be an arrogant smile on his face was his way of quietly praying and practicing nonviolence to ward off a threat he anticipated coming from the Native American. OK, but none of the boys stepped up to the Black Israelites in this way.
“When I took that drum and hit that first beat … it was a supplication to God,” Mr. Phillips told the Cincinnati Enquirer. “Look at us, God, look at what is going on here; my America is being torn apart by racism, hatred, bigotry.”
The Hebrew Israelites appear to have been the biggest instigators of the trouble, but the boys didn’t help their case by surrounding Mr. Phillips and responding like a mob to a perceived threat in a way reminiscent of a Trump rally. At least no one yelled “Pocahontas.”
For his part, Mr. Phillips was naive to approach the boys without evidence that they were culturally sensitive enough not to feel threatened by him, given the insults rained on them from the black protesters. But Nick Sandmann and his fellow students, if they had even minimal understanding of the nation’s violent treatment of Native Americans, should have stepped aside.
This is where we are in America. Despite wearing red MAGA hats, the boys saw themselves as nonviolent prayer warriors who had come hundreds of miles to fight on behalf of the unborn.
The Black Israelites saw themselves as the most orthodox expression of Christianity and Judaism in America, even while spewing hatred in every direction. At best, they are the flip side of white nationalism and the antithesis of Martin Luther King.
Every group at the Mall that day was there to practice a politics of grievance, which is every American’s right, of course. In 1963, MLK stood on the same steps and gave the most utopian speech possible about the kind of people we should aspire to be.
A year later, Bob Dylan recorded “One Too Many Mornings.” It includes a line that is a lot closer to our American reality than MLK’s lofty sentiments 56 years ago: “You’re right from your side and I’m right from mine.” We’re now living through an American “Rashomon.”
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.