Several weeks ago, Andrew Johnson, a wrestler from Buena Regional High School near Atlantic City, N.J., was given a startling ultimatum by a referee minutes before his match — cut your hair or forfeit.
Decency and fairness usually dictate that potentially disqualifying factors such as uniforms, length of hair or fingernails, grooming or hygiene issues are discussed by refs, coaches and wrestlers long before a match. There was no such discussion when Buena Regional faced off against Oakcrest High School in Hamilton, N.J.
Referee Alan Maloney, 62, was late. When he arrived, he was in the mood to enforce the rules as capriciously as possible. Andrew Johnson’s dreadlocks weren’t a problem before Mr. Maloney made an issue of them. In the past, he covered his hair with a net and headgear prescribed by the New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association.
That wasn’t good enough for Mr. Maloney, who insisted that Andrew was not in compliance with NJSIAA rules despite wrestling the entire season with locks. Buena Regional was given 90 seconds to comply.
Clearly anguished, the young wrestler consented to his hair being trimmed to a length Mr. Maloney considered acceptable. His team cheered him on, but it was clear that the adults in a position to protect Andrew Johnson allowed a referee to get away with an irrational order that looked a lot like racial bias.
Andrew won his match, which was a nice downpayment on the karma that would soon be rolling Mr. Maloney’s way. When the referee grabbed Andrew’s hand to raise it in victory, the young man snatched it down before turning away in disgust. It was part of the rage that fueled his victory. For a second, he resembled Bob Marley.
Read More
Ever since the video of the drama went viral, I’ve been thinking about how some folks lack the capacity to be embarrassed by their clumsy displays of power. Instead of registering his concern but allowing the match to proceed with a warning that the length of Andrew’s dreadlocks be addressed before the next scheduled competition, Mr. Maloney refused to acknowledge that Andrew had been in good standing until that point.
When Andrew offered to cover his locks under a league-sanctioned net, the referee refused and signaled his cultural obliviousness by insisting that his hair “wasn’t in its natural state.”
How would a 62-year-old white guy even know what the “natural state” of a black teenager’s hair is?
Would it really have killed Mr. Maloney if he had given Andrew Johnson the benefit of the doubt? How is the length of a young black man’s hair an advantage in a wrestling match?
And given that he arrived to the competition late and didn’t register his objections at a time when reasonable accommodations or arguments could have taken place, wouldn’t it have been to Mr. Maloney’s advantage to have extended a little grace toward Andrew, even if he believed the young man was in violation of the rules?
Instead, Mr. Maloney orchestrated a cynical display of petty power and prerogative by forcing an athlete to choose between his team and his bodily integrity.
Because he’s a “team player,” Andrew agreed to have his locks cut. It was a shameful moment for high school athletics.
Referees have a tenuous legitimacy at best that depends upon whether a crowd considers them fair or not. It turns out that Mr. Maloney was operating under a cloud of suspicion for racial bias even before he set foot on the court. Two years ago, Mr. Maloney was suspended for using a racial slur against a black referee at a party where both were arguing about wine.
At one point, Mr. Maloney poked referee Preston Hamilton in the chest and uttered a racial epithet to his face. Mr. Hamilton lifted Mr. Maloney and slammed him to the ground. Both were suspended, but Mr. Maloney had his suspension overturned on appeal, as did Mr. Hamilton.
“It was two men, a group of guys, having fun and it was a slip-up,” Mr. Maloney told a local newspaper. “If you can’t see past that, then I don’t know what to say. I made a mistake and I apologized for it. And it was accepted.”
See how that works? Mr. Maloney fully expected to be given the benefit of the doubt for using a racial slur against a colleague, though he initially denied it. One would have thought that, once reinstated, he would bend over backward to avoid being associated with racial controversy again.
Alas, Mr. Maloney is not that sensible. He turned what should have been a routine wrestling bout into another national flashpoint on race. Fortunately, the overwhelming consensus is that Mr. Maloney abused his authority and almost certainly acted out of racial bias, given the flimsiness of Andrew Johnson’s alleged infraction. He has few defenders.
The NJSIAA is reviewing the referee’s record and the incident involving Andrew. He can’t referee any more wrestling matches in Jersey pending the outcome of the investigation. He could be banned for life.
Was the exercise of power over a student athlete’s hair worth the resulting firestorm? Probably not, but even stupid and self-defeating actions can seem justifiable when it comes to ensuring a false sense of public order. After all, someone has to enforce arbitrarily imposed rules and traditions.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.