When Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi walked into the Saudi consulate in Istanbul several weeks ago to pick up documents to marry his Turkish fiancee, he believed there were limits to even the cruelty and stupidity of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman.

He didn’t imagine the brazenness of the regime he had criticized for years extended to killing someone like him — a journalist employed by one of the most influential newspapers in the world — one with the resources to investigate whatever harm befell one of its reporters in far away Istanbul.

While Mr. Khashoggi failed to imagine the worst that could befall him, the reports of what allegedly happened to him that day, including dismemberment and torture, conform to what we already know of the 32-year-old Saudi prince’s penchant for blood and brutality.

But like the title organ in Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart,” Jamal Khashoggi’s disembodied fingers continue pointing to MBS’ circumstantial guilt and eventual reckoning.

Advertise with us

Suddenly, the impetuous young ruler who convinced so many supporters in the West that he was a “reformer” looked like a man with a host of irredeemable character flaws. But there have always been signs that Mohammed bin Salman was far less than the sum of his hype.

When MBS confined dozens of Saudi royals and rivals to a luxury hotel in Ridyah for a shakedown of epic proportions, the world reasoned he was merely exercising the prerogatives all medievalist rulers reserve for themselves as they consolidate power.

Kidnapping the prime minister of Lebanon and coercing him into saying things on Saudi state-run TV that he didn’t believe revealed MBS’ essential thuggishness, but that’s hardly a disqualifying trait for a Saudi prince in modern times.

The relentless bombardment of Yemen’s civilians from the air with American weapons has prompted much hand-wringing in the West, but the only sanctions Ridyah has suffered so far amount to nothing more than random spittle flecks from the flapping gums of transaction-minded diplomats.

While it is true that MBS is also a documented killer of children — most recently a school bus full of them targeted with aerial bombs during an outing in Yemen — he usually manages to do the unspeakable while hiding behind several layers of plausible denial.

Advertise with us

That’s why what happened to Jamal Khashoggi in Istanbul seems both absurd and stupid beyond words. The kingdom and its apologists have settled upon a narrative that requires that we believe that Saudi Arabia is the world’s most incompetent police state and that its leader is more Col. Henry Blake during the first season of “M*A*S*H” than Orwell’s all-seeing Big Brother.

According to a spokesman for the embattled prince, Mr. Khashoggi was likely suffocated during what he describes as a “brawl” at the consulate’s office. Eighteen high-level Saudis have been arrested for “going too far.”

Allegedly, their original mission was to get Mr. Khashoggi to agree to return to the kingdom where his rights as a dissident would be respected by MBS. Because of the incompetence of the rendition team, the writer died. No mention of severed fingers or torture — just passive language describing the inexplicable death of one tough hombre of a journalist.

Alas, the panicked men, who flew to Istanbul with the most benign of intentions the day before, covered up a “terrible accident” involving minuscule amounts of torture and a bone saw. Some outlets are reporting that a body double for Mr. Khashoggi wore his clothes while walking the streets of Istanbul so that the image would be captured by surveillance cameras.

The Saudis insist that Jamal Khashoggi instigated his own death by resisting those who wanted to kill him. In the totalitarian world of the Saudi high command, absurdity is a preexisting condition. The “sensationalistic media” that exists outside of Saudi control insist on calling what happened to Mr. Khashoggi a homicide even though his body has not been accounted for.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, the journalist’s severed fingers, now ghostly digits lodged forever in our imagination, continue tapping out a far more compelling counter-narrative than the lame alibis of the regime that murdered him.

How ironic that Turkish strongman President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, a fellow press-hating authoritarian, authorized the release of information particularly damning to MBS. Whatever happened to honor among blackguards?

Of course, journalists all over the world take what happened to Jamal Khashoggi personally because even the most advanced democracies are only two or three bad election cycles away from tyranny and a loss of press freedom. What happened to Mr. Khashoggi is a cautionary tale writ large for the worldwide community of journalists.

While it isn’t likely CNN’s Jim Acosta will be lured to the White House anytime soon for an “exclusive” only to be dismembered by a waiting contingent of Trump-loving Proud Boys, it is no longer beyond our capacity to imagine it.

Journalists from Thailand and the Philippines to China and Russia are either killed or arrested regularly for pointing out that Big Brother isn’t wearing any pants.

Advertise with us

Thanks to Mr. Khashoggi’s death, we can now picture the worst that can happen to a journalist living in a country where they’re routinely referred to by those in power as “the enemy of the people.”

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.