Last week, a white police officer in Chicago was convicted of killing a black teenager four years ago. Officer Jason Van Dyke shot 17-year-old Laquan McDonald 16 times.

The shooting was witnessed by more than a dozen armed officers who had McDonald surrounded. He had been suspected of breaking into a car. He was walking down the street carrying a 3-inch knife that wasn’t pointed in any officer’s direction. He was not resisting arrest, but he was suspected of being drunk or high because he was walking “erratically.”

McDonald wasn’t threatening anyone, but when Van Dyke and his partner arrived on the scene minutes after other police officers had surrounded him, he complained that the teenager was still mobile. Van Dyke testified that he had a premonition he would have to be the one to shoot McDonald.

As self-fulfilling prophecies go, Van Dyke was on the money. He testified that the teenager briefly gave him an “evil look” that terrified him. Despite the presence of armed colleagues and a healthy distance between them, Van Dyke “feared for his life” and fired at the teenager.

Advertise with us

No other officer joined in the deadly fusillade, not even Van Dyke’s partner. No other officer testified to feeling anything near the same level of terror or concern for his safety. At his trial, Van Dyke’s partner said he believed the officer did the right thing, according to his perception of what was happening.

The dashboard camera that recorded the event undermined every aspect of Van Dyke’s testimony, which was a mass of contradictory and self-incriminating statements. Still, Van Dyke argued that, regardless of what the camera recorded, he believed that he and his partner were in imminent danger of losing their lives at the hands of a staggering teenager despite the police officers’ superior numbers, Kevlar vests and guns.

At first, the shooting of Laquan McDonald attracted little notice, meriting only the briefest of mentions in the papers and on the local news. McDonald’s family wasn’t satisfied with the police rationale for why they faced the grim duty of burying a loved one with 16 bullet holes in his body. They made a stink about it that came to resonate across the country.

The shooting of McDonald was part of a pattern of difficult-to-rationalize police shootings across the country that were leaving black men dead after what should have been routine encounters. It didn’t help that Chicago had a documented record of brutality against the city’s black community stretching back decades. Chicago police operated in a culture of violence that they justified as a necessary bulwark against the internecine violence of the neighborhoods they patrolled.

Suddenly, a critical mass of outrage had been reached. When the dashboard footage finally emerged after lawsuits, family pressure and widespread demonstrations, activists were ready. The political establishment was on the defensive, including the mayor, the district attorney and the police chief. The shooting of McDonald was going to have consequences unprecedented in the city’s history.

Advertise with us

Last week, Van Dyke was found guilty of second-degree murder and 16 counts of aggravated battery with a firearm. It was the first conviction of an officer for murder in Chicago in half a century.

Most of the city’s police officers on duty now weren’t alive the last time a cop was convicted of murder in the line of duty in Chicago. It’s always been more a theoretical possibility than something ever likely to happen as long as an officer could persuade one lone juror that he or she had been in imminent danger, had been “in fear for my life.”

In any other week, the conviction of Jason Van Dyke would had led national newscasts, but it was eclipsed by wall-to-wall Brett Kavanaugh coverage everywhere except in Chicago. There was a collective exhale of relief as planned marches became nonviolent celebrations of the verdict. No arrests were made and there was, for the first time in years, a rough consensus that justice finally had prevailed in Chicago.

In the Pittsburgh area, the pressure exerted on criminal justice institutions after the police shooting of Antwon Rose in East Pittsburgh is following a similar pattern in advance of the officer’s trial.

As in Chicago, every march is an announcement that people now have a higher standard for what constitutes a justifiable shooting of a civilian and that they are determined to make local police departments acknowledge this in their training.

Advertise with us

Every blocked intersection is a declaration of war against bureaucratic inertia and inaction. Every demand that a politician or police chief resign is a declaration that the days of remaining passive in the face of systemic injustice are over.

Going forward, every election that punishes a foot-dragging district attorney, forces a police chief to resign or dissuades an unpopular mayor from running for another term will be understood for what it is — a victory for effective civic engagement that stretches from the streets to the ballot box. This is what democracy looks like.

The people of Chicago refused to be apathetic about the unjustifiable shooting of Laquan McDonald. The result of their principled agitation was a jury trial in which a murder conviction was handed down to a police officer by a jury of his peers.

One conviction will not solve all of Chicago’s myriad problems, of course, including its epidemic of non-police-involved shootings, but it does take away the assumption that those whose job it is to enforce the law are somehow above it.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.