Antwon Rose II would have preferred not to have been the inspiration for protests that made him a household name over the past week. He said as much in a poem he wrote two years ago, prophesying a moment when his mother would lament his death and he would enter the history of this region as just another grim statistic.
He didn’t want that. One reason the 17-year-old bolted from the back seat of the car that was stopped for suspicion of being involved in a drive-by shooting was that he could feel his prophesied mortality closing in on him. Antwon leapt out of the car with only the slimmest of hopes that he could outrun the specter that has terrified him for so many years.
East Pittsburgh police Officer Michael Rosfeld, the man who shot Antwon Rose three times in the back, has yet to offer a justification for what he did that has filtered out to the public.
Unlike civilians who expect to be hauled into an interrogation room and pressed to give an account of themselves even after demanding a lawyer, police officers benefit from a quirk in the system that allows them to take as much time as need to get their stories straight.
Consequently, Officer Rosfeld, who has not been charged, has kept his contact with investigating authorities to a minimum. All we know for sure is that he is hunkered down with a high-priced criminal defense attorney crafting a narrative explaining what he did, should he ever have to face a jury of his peers.
There aren’t many people in my circle of friends and acquaintances who believe what happened to Antwon Rose II had anything to do with the pursuit of justice. As far as I know, I don’t live in a neighborhood where anyone would make excuses for an officer shooting a teenager in the back simply for fleeing the scene.
Shooting Antwon was not an action taken in the name of self-defense as any rational person understands it. Even under the most liberal interpretation of an officer’s prerogative to use lethal force when he or she feels their own life is threatened, it would require a Herculean leap of imagination to explain the ambiguous danger represented by a teen’s exposed back.
Still, we live in a community where “extenuating circumstances” and justification for shootings like this one are easy to come by. Just skim the comments under news stories about the killing of Antwon Rose for confirmation that his life is considered acceptable collateral damage by a lot of people. That this police action would be unimaginable outside of the black community is a given.
While I don’t know anyone personally who is callous enough to say out loud that Antwon “got what was coming to him for running,” I know that such people exist and that their only sympathy is for Officer Rosfeld — mostly because he is a white cop and his victim is a black boy who doesn’t play for a professional sports team they’re invested in.
They’ve seen the video and have even heard the racial epithet shouted by a bystander at the end of the recording, but their sympathies are weighted in favor of the destruction of the black body, whether law allows for it or not.
The internet trolls of today — just as their great-grandparents favored lynching as a means of social control and their great-great-great-grandpappies joined posses to enforce the Fugitive Slave Act — see no incompatibility between justice and the everyday carnage caused by implicit bias among the ranks of police officers.
“He shouldn’t have run,” they say, adding that the officer had a legitimate fear that if the teenager got away, he could hurt someone or return to the scene and ambush him. Shooting Antwon Rose was merely eliminating a perpetrator of future crime. What could be more rational? Officer Rosfeld is a hero in this twisted scenario.
That is why I believe it is difficult for anyone with a conscience to sympathize with the fear that compels an officer to shoot an unarmed suspect in the back, especially when he is running away.
It could either be a failure of imagination on my part or moral revulsion, given the officer’s lack of empathy as he squeezed off those shots into a fleeing black body with the efficiency of a video game. What do you think someone like Officer Rosfeld would do to a fleeing white kid in his own neighborhood under similar circumstances?
Media reports about videos of a shooting Antwon was allegedly involved in have circulated and been discredited. A report that gunpowder residue was taken from his hands has also been strenuously denied by authorities, leaving Officer Rosfeld’s defenders to double-down on their insistence that running away from a cop with a gun clip in your pocket is guilt of something worthy of summary execution.
In response to this and many other outrages, a multiracial coalition of citizens has taken to the streets to disrupt regional complacency and the assumption that unjustified shootings under color of authority will be tolerated anymore. Antwon Rose never wanted to be a symbol, but in death, he’s more than just a statistic. He’s a call to action.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.