On Wednesday, Alice Marie Johnson ran out of the federal prison in Pickens County, Alabama, into the arms of a family that had reasonably doubted they would ever embrace their matriarch outside prison walls again.
Now 63, Ms. Johnson had never stopped praying for that moment of freedom since the day she was sentenced to life without possibility of parole on a non-violent drug charge in 1996.
It was her first offense. Unfortunately, Alice Johnson had the bad luck of being convicted and sentenced in the crack era — a time when fear of “underclass super-predators” whipped up by politicians stripped nuance from judicial deliberations and replaced it with one-size-fits-all justice.
While serving her life sentence, Ms. Johnson, who had been an exemplary FedEx employee until she lost her job shortly after her decades-long marriage ended, turned her attention to being an exemplary prisoner.
Every day, Alice Johnson proved that the system had been unjust to sentence her to die behind bars when actual murderers who scoffed at rehabilitation were released on parole daily, simply because their crimes didn’t involve drugs. She became an ordained minister and a mentor to younger prisoners.
Sentenced during the Clinton administration, she suffered stoically through two terms of George W. Bush before applying for clemency during the presidency of Barack Obama. Of all our recent presidents, Mr. Obama understood the racial bias and arbitrariness of the nation’s drug laws. He had experimented with drugs himself in his youth. He understood the dramatic disparities in sentencing for those who sold crack versus those who sold powdered cocaine and challenged his Justice Department to address it.
Even though Mr. Obama commuted more sentences and freed more convicted drug offenders than all of his predecessors combined, Ms. Johnson’s petition for clemency never made it to his desk because the Justice Department recommended against her all three times she tried.
Even though Ms. Johnson was sitting in federal prison based on laws that everyone agreed disproportionately penalized black people, the bureaucracy couldn’t see its way past the procedural Catch-22 that condemned a model prisoner with no previous record to life behind bars.
The Johnson family thought Mr. Obama would issue a pardon during the last months of his final term, when hundreds of non-violent drug offenders were freed, but it didn’t happen despite tens of thousands of names on petitions for him to do so. Mr. Obama, always a cautious politician, was not prepared to go against the recommendations of a Justice Department that continued to see Alice Johnson as a threat.
Can anyone blame the Johnson family’s full-throated praise for President Donald Trump commuting their matriarch’s sentence after his son-in-law Jared Kushner and reality TV star Kim Kardashian West interceded on her behalf? If going the conventional route reveals only a continued failure of imagination on the system’s part, then it only makes sense to appeal to a president who has even less respect for bureaucratic convention and departmental protocol than he does for justice.
And make no mistake: Donald Trump doesn’t care about black people or justice — see his incendiary comments about the Central Park Five or the racial makeup of his Cabinet for confirmation of that statement.
Meanwhile, the Justice Department under Attorney General Jeff Sessions wants to reverse the prison reform momentum of recent years and fill prisons with low-level drug offenders again. Still, Mr. Trump is a master at exploiting opportunities that make him look good, whether the effort is transparently hypocritical or not.
In recent weeks, Mr. Trump posthumously pardoned Jack Johnson, the first black heavyweight boxing champion, at the behest of actor Sylvester Stallone, so he probably considers himself the go-to-guy for instant justice for non-threatening black people. Pardoning a dead boxer and a model prisoner doesn’t remotely address the structural problems and bias that are only getting worse under this administration.
That’s why it meant nothing to Mr. Trump to free a 63-year-old reformed felon at the request of fellow celebrity Kim Kardashian, while leaving hundreds of thousands more without hope — unless a whole bunch of celebrities willing to genuflect before the president at the White House take interest in their causes, too.
While one can only be happy for the Johnson family and the end of its two-decade-long nightmare, there’s a sickening realization that justice doesn’t always result from formal procedure and that uniform caution aids and abets injustice. Ironically, Mr. Trump proves that breaking with protocol can sometimes result in a just outcome and that presidents should be willing to take chances.
Though the Obama administration accomplished much in criminal justice reform, it missed an opportunity with Ms. Johnson and possibly thousands of other chances to right systemic wrongs. Bad laws and procedures will most likely remain in place during the Trump presidency even as he arbitrarily frees deserving and undeserving clemency petitioners. His justice looks bigger and more magnanimous.
If the underlying structure that makes the mass incarceration of people like Ms. Johnson possible doesn’t change, every pardon becomes just another episode of a reality TV show — more sound and fury signifying nothing.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.