How does one get the benefit of the doubt in a country where you don’t look like the people usually doing the doubting? This is a question that people of color and minorities of all persuasions have struggled with since colonial times.
It appears that those who fled persecution and stigma in the Old World couldn’t wait to set up a similar system to persecute new enemies in the New World.
The cycle of finger-pointing and suspicion continues to this day, but after several hundred years, America decided that lynch mobs were a little too scary and unpredictable. Now calling the cops on “the Other” — usually someone black or brown minding his or her own business — is the preferred way of keeping those dusky undesirables in line.
Recent cases of using the cops to enforce color lines around certain spaces are deservedly notorious. The two black men who were arrested at a Starbucks in Philadelphia last month for not buying a drink while waiting for a business partner is a case in point. Seven or eight officers rushed to the scene on the basis of one call from a white female manager. No crime was committed, but there was plenty of racial bias in the air.
The two men spent eight hours in police custody, which sparked weeks of protests and a personal apology to the accused from the CEO of Starbucks, who flew to Philly to personally conduct crisis management. The manager and Starbucks have parted ways.
Starbucks settled with the two wrongfully accused men for an undisclosed amount. This month, the company will close all of its North America stores for an afternoon of mandatory implicit bias training.
The CEO of Nordstrom Rack also had to engage in shuttle diplomacy when three black teens were briefly detained by police at a St. Louis outlet after being falsely accused of shoplifting by a white customer. Not only had the boys not stolen anything, they had receipts proving that they had bought things to “show them that we’re equal and we didn’t have to steal anything,” one is quoted as saying.
The interesting development in this story is that the teens also thanked the cops for hearing them out and quickly siding with them once it was obvious that they were shopping for their prom like other high school seniors — not thieving.
Cops are getting wise to the game. The ubiquity of camera phones is beginning to show what hadn’t always been obvious before — seriously disturbed white folks all over the country are calling 911 and using cops and security guards as proxy enforcers of what they once considered exclusive white space.
Bob Marley’s granddaughter and three friends were surrounded by five or six Rialto, Calif., police cars while exiting an Airbnb with suitcases they were putting in the trunk of their car. A white neighbor was suspicious of them because they didn’t wave back after she waved to them. Though the cops professed not to know what an Airbnb was, they were smart enough to know the incident would go viral, so they behaved themselves. The women were allowed to leave after a short detention.
Darren Martin, a black former staffer with the Obama White House, was stopped and questioned by police while moving into his Upper West Side apartment in New York City recently. A neighbor called the cops and insisted a burglary was in progress.
Six cops arrived ready to execute justice. Mr. Martin calmly explained to the officers what he was doing while live-streaming the encounter on Instagram. It was clear that a white neighbor had panicked after seeing a black man moving into a formerly all-white building.
Two Native American brothers touring Colorado State University were separated from the rest of their tour group by security police operating on a tip from a panicked parent of one of the other prospective students. She said the boys were creepy and up to something. The police held them for five minutes before they were allowed to rejoin the group after it moved on. Though the boys were guilty of nothing, their mother insisted they make the seven-hour drive back home rather than risk further humiliation or worse.
The manager of an LA Fitness in Secaucus, N.J., called the cops on a black member and a guest last month. It was never clear why he wanted the men removed since the member was paid up and he had the right to bring a guest for a workout. He wanted to terminate the gentleman’s membership on the spot and wanted the cops to enforce it. They didn’t. They told the manager he had no right to do it. The video went viral. The manager and two other employees were quickly fired. Three cheers for reasonable cops.
The most dramatic recent case is the Yale graduate student who fell asleep in her building’s study hall only to have the cops called on her by another student — a white female who felt she was violating the rules by sleeping in a common space.
The cops seemed embarrassed by their part in the drama. They’re starting to catch on. Skepticism is warranted when it comes to 911 calls from panicky white people.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.