The conventional wisdom about the 2018 version of rapper/producer Kanye West is that he’s “crazy” and that he’s never made a lot of sense even on his best days.
Alas, the problem with conventional wisdom is that some of us are old enough to remember when “Yeezy,” or “Ye” as he is referred to by his fans, was proclaimed the future of hip-hop.
We remember his manufactured “feud” with Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson back in 2007. Both artists released albums on the same day with intention of settling an argument about what strain of hip-hop owned the future — 50 Cent’s party and gangsta raps or Ye’s experimental confections and literate narratives.
So it came down to Kanye’s “Graduation,” the final installment of his popular “College Drop Out” trilogy, versus 50 Cent’s hyper-aggressive and misogynistic “Curtis” for the soul of hip-hop.
Kanye won the battle at the register and with the critics, but he also beat 50 Cent where it really counted — the hearts and minds of hip-hop fans.
That’s when the almost worshipful treatment of Kanye West as some kind of musical “genius” and oracle of the street began. It has barely relented over the last decade despite periods of utter pretentiousness and nervous exhaustion on his part.
It isn’t unusual for self-aggrandizing rappers to refer to themselves in the third person, but Kanye began glibly comparing himself to titans in fields other than music like Picasso, Bill Gates and Steve Jobs, too. It was embarrassing even then, but at least there was no doubt that all of his name-dropping was the result of reading some books (or so it was assumed).
Today, Kanye West brags about how little he reads and how much he doesn’t know about American politics. Still, he adamantly maintains that he’s a “free-thinker” because he allegedly holds to no dogma or ideology. He name-drops obscure black conservative personalities like Candace Owens and proclaims his “love” of President Donald Trump to prove he’s post-ideological and attuned to the hearts of individuals — not their politics.
He equates being a Democrat with having a plantation mentality, a change of attitude that is cheered almost every night on Fox News where almost every host now claims to be a Kanye fan.
In recent weeks, he’s signaled a shift in thinking from his infamous post-Katrina declaration that “George Bush doesn’t care about black people” in 2005 to insisting that Donald Trump hasn’t done anything to “hurt” black people in the 15 months he’s been in office. He even wears an autographed MAGA hat on Instagram and calls the president “my boy.”
But it was the comments Kanye made about slavery during an interview with the paparazzi site TMZ that threaten to strip him of any relevance for years to come: “When you hear about slavery for 400 years, for 400 years? That sounds like a choice,” he said. “Like, you were there for 400 years and it’s all of y’all? It’s like we’re mentally in prison. I like the word ‘prison’ because slavery goes too direct to the idea of blacks.”
Just when you thought things couldn’t get much stupider or more incoherent, Yeezy addressed the entire TMZ newsroom with this rhetorical question: “Do you feel like I’m being free?” he asked. “[Am] I thinking free?”
Van Lathan, one of the few black TMZ reporters, stepped up to smack down the hip-hop icon: “I actually don’t think you’re thinking anything,” Mr. Lathan said. “I think what you’re doing right now is actually the absence of thought. And the reason why I feel like that is because, Kanye, you’re entitled to your opinion. You’re entitled to believe whatever you want. But there is fact, and real-world, real-life consequences behind everything you just said.
“And while you’re making music and being an artist and living the life that you’ve earned by being a ‘genius,’ the rest of us in society have to deal with these threats to our lives. We have to deal with the marginalization that has come from the 400 years of slavery that you said, for our people, was a choice.
“Frankly, I’m disappointed, I’m appalled and, brother, I am unbelievably hurt by the fact that you have morphed into something, to me, that’s not real.”
Van Lathan’s furious eloquence was everyone’s furious eloquence at that moment. Kanye West was out of his depth and he knew it. He later cornered Mr. Lathan and tried to debate him, but the damage was done. America would see the exchange on TMZ within hours and reach its own conclusion about Kanye’s fitness to embody anyone’s hopes and dreams.
There’s a lot of disillusionment about Kanye West these days, but it isn’t his fault. He was held to an impossible standard from the beginning. He failed because he was expected to “be black” for millions of people when he barely has the capacity to understand who he is. No wonder he lost his way.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.