Earlier this week in a New York Times op-ed (republished on this page Thursday), retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens called for a repeal of the Second Amendment.

Justice Stevens was one of four dissenters in District of Columbia v. Heller, the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark 2008 ruling that affirmed an individual American’s right to bear arms (and not to worry about what the term “well regulated militia” meant in the original text).

The crux of the 97-year-old former jurist’s argument was that the gun lobby could be neutralized as a force in politics if the Heller case was overturned by a constitutional amendment to repeal the Second Amendment.

Justice Stevens’ critics have mocked his contention that such a move would be as “simple” as he made it sound, given the political and cultural realities of American life. As the most heavily armed population on the planet, even Americans who don’t own assault guns are fiercely protective of the option to walk into a gun show or retail store and buy as much military-grade weaponry as whole units possessed during the Civil War.

Advertise with us

It is a constitutional assumption according to the majority of the Supreme Court and a metaphysical certainty if you are a believer in a certain kind of American exceptionalism.

The right to stock up on a warehouse worth of weapons if your budget allows it is such an inextricable part of our cultural identity that citizens would be more inclined to wonder if it is possible to even be an American without it. How in the world can you be an American without the right to kill as many of your fellow Americans as you legitimately feel threatened by? Isn’t this a right bestowed on us by God, the Devil or whatever deity was running the show when our slave Republic was in its infancy?

The question feels absurd when presented in such an insanely paranoid way, but it is the same brutal logic that underlies a police officer’s right to kill civilians without consequence even if the victim is found to have wielded nothing more dangerous than a cell phone. “I feared for my life” is typed or scribbled on every police report attempting to rationalize a power imbalance.

Shooting unarmed civilians who present no threat is consistent with the practices and training of most police departments as we’ve learned from several high-profile cases this week. The gun lobby merely takes logic rooted in routine institutional fear of black and brown suspects and spreads it around the civilian population.

Even as crime drops precipitously, the gun lobby continues a drumbeat of fear and loathing that finds fertile ground in a divided country. Like any officer confronted with a riddled corpse after emptying a cartridge of bullets into a once-breathing human being, average American gun owners have permission to kill other average Americans — armed or not — if they feel their lives are “legitimately” threatened. Because this is America, there is no obligation to retreat. Settle your business with words or guns as you see fit and deal with the legal fallout knowing that no jury will question your fundamental assumption that another person’s life is yours to take if you’re sufficiently scared.

Advertise with us

Still, for all the scoffing and mockery engendered by Justice Stevens’ op-ed, most of the civilized world agrees with him. I’d guess that most Americans do, too. The problem is the failure of imagination on the part of our elected leaders that makes all meaningful gun reform a zero-sum game.

Because of his advanced age, Justice Stevens has seen with his own eyes nearly a century’s worth of social and political change, so nothing is too revolutionary to him. He’s seen black folks and women go from invisibility, to being second-class citizens, to being on the cusp of something that resembles equality.

Justice Stevens remembers the early planes and automobiles and how those industrial breakthroughs gave birth to the technology that took us to the moon and will soon make artificial intelligence a reality. Given his long-term perspective, the idea of a “relic” like the Second Amendment hamstringing social and political progress in perpetuity is almost as absurd as adhering to the three-fifths compromise that once marginalized black people. Just because it is in the Constitution doesn’t make it sacred

, especially if it contributes to the kind of carnage the Founders couldn’t have possibly imagined.

One day, the Second Amendment as we know it will be gone. As we gear up for unimagined breakthroughs in science and human development, our bloodiest amendment will either be amended into something saner or jettisoned entirely by a generation that is no longer afraid of its own shadow. The idea of Americans without guns sounds oxymoronic right now, but the court of public opinion will vindicate Justice John Paul Stevens’ audacious vision, if we’re lucky.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.