In the wake of l’affaire Harvey Weinstein, Hollywood is officially the sleaziest work environment imaginable — except for every other sleazy work environment from the heights of corporate America to the local fast-food joints. The media, of course, is no exception to this rule.

Every morning begins with a new test of conscience when it comes to whether to patronize actors, directors and producers we’ve most likely never met and never will meet.

Remember the good ol’ days of sexual harassment in Hollywood? The binaries were long-dead actors and directors like Fatty Arbuckle and Alfred Hitchcock on one end of the awful human scale, and Woody Allen and Roman Polanski on the other end.

The old binaries were shaken up a bit with the inclusion of Bill Cosby, who has north of 60 women accusing him of either attempted sexual assault or worse over a five-decade period.

Advertise with us

Then along came Harvey Weinstein, arguably one of the most powerful producers in Hollywood history for decades. For a time in October, it appeared that nearly every major actress who came to prominence in the last two decades had a Weinstein horror story of assault or sexual coercion to share.

The very successful #MeToo campaign on social media created a bridge to women (and men) outside of Tinseltown to tell their stories of sexual harassment in the workplace. And, boy, did they.

In the wake of so much disgust, Mr. Weinstein lost his wife, his family, his company, his social and business cachet, and untold millions in future earnings. He may even face sexual assault charges. His name will be forever associated with work-related exploitation.

Mr. Weinstein was quickly eclipsed by director James Toback, who has been accused by 310 women of harassing them. Meanwhile, actor Dustin Hoffman has been called out in the pages of The Hollywood Reporter as a sexual harasser. Actor Anthony Rapp said that in 1986 actor Kevin Spacey tried to seduce him after a party at his New York apartment; Mr. Spacey was in his mid-20s, Mr. Rapp was 14. Of course one is allowed to ask how such a young boy found himself at a party thrown by a very closeted, but successful Hollywood actor, but that wouldn’t excuse the act of attempted predation that allegedly occurred.

I immediately thought of “American Beauty” and “The Usual Suspects,” two of my favorite films starring Mr. Spacey. Though I’m not as much a fan of his recent work on “House of Cards,” I wondered if as a good liberal, I’ll be called upon by my “woke” friends to go into boycott mode when it comes to all things Kevin Spacey, past and future.

Advertise with us

And what about Mr. Hoffman’s work in “Midnight Cowboy,” “The Graduate,” “Kramer vs. Kramer,” and “Tootsie”? These are some of the best films of the second half of the 20th century. Are we really supposed to turn our old DVDs of those movies into frisbees and toss them because Mr. Hoffman has been revealed to be something of a lecherous beast?

I went through a version of this argument with friends and colleagues when the Woody Allen / Soon-Yi Farrow Previn / Mia Farrow scandal erupted in the early 1990s. Mr. Allen did seduce the adopted daughter of Ms. Farrow, his longtime girlfriend. He married Ms. Previn and they’ve remained together for decades.

Whenever I name “Annie Hall” as my favorite movie of all time, I get immediate pushback from folks who insist they swore Mr. Allen off even before he was accused of sexually molesting Dylan Farrow, another of Ms. Farrow’s adopted children.

If Ms. Farrow, who related her story to New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof in 2014, is telling the truth, it is a story that should sicken all of us. But I have to be honest here — I don’t think I’m the only one who separates the artist from the work he or she brings into the world.

It would be impossible to read the great works of literature by Oscar Wilde, Rimbaud or Celine, or appreciate many of the greatest painters, musicians and filmmakers of the last 500 years, if their sex lives — criminal or not — were entered into the equation. It would be impossible to enjoy Picasso or listen to Miles Davis if one fixated on the women they used their fame to seduce, exploit and denigrate.

Advertise with us

But someone like James Toback is not Picasso, so I can honestly go my whole life without seeing another one of his films. But I can’t live without Picasso’s “Guernica.” I also feel I can’t walk away from “The Graduate” or Mr. Polanski’s “Rosemary’s Baby.”

The odds are that in the coming days and weeks, artists many of us love and venerate will be accused of terrible things. Artists are edgy and morally unruly, which doesn’t excuse them for their crimes in the least. Only popular music icons will be exempted. Debauchery and exploitation are baked into their entertainment models.

Still, we have to decide whether we are going to be like the iconoclasts who lit the bonfire of the vanities in Florence in 1497 because Savonarola insisted that most of the painters of Renaissance Italy were of low moral character. There are laws to deal with artists who are also criminals, but let’s not put a litmus test to their art.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.