Recently, the Pittsburgh Art Commission recommended the removal of the Stephen Foster statue from its place of honor in Schenley Plaza in Oakland to a more “properly contextualized” location (i.e., out of public view).
The Art Commission did the right thing. The statue of the 19th century’s greatest American songwriter has already spent more than a century looking down on the public. Though the grinning, banjo playing negro sitting at his feet happens to be in the immediate line of fire for his cold gaze, the public also has reason to feel condescended to for having put up with it for so long.
Stephen Collins Foster’s massive contribution to the American songbook is beyond debate, but the workmanlike bronze statue erected in his honor has always been an embarrassment. It was destined for offensive obsolescence the moment that racial attitudes caught up with the chronological number of the century it was imbedded in.
Unveiled with great fanfare 117 years ago, the bronze sculpture of Lawrenceville’s brightest son was cheered on by 50,000 Pittsburghers as it was transported to its way to its original home in Highland Park.
Designed by a committee that included banker Andrew Mellon, Pennsylvania Railroad mogul Robert Pitcairn and Pittsburgh Press editor T.J. Keenan, the 10-foot tall statue was sculpted to order by artist Giuseppe Moretti.
It is not the work of a singular artistic vision, which may account for its aesthetic paucity. Even by the standards of the late 19th century, Moretti’s sculpture was already a dull and uninspired hunk of sentimental trash the moment it emerged from the kiln.
To say that no one “loves” the Stephen Foster sculpture is an understatement. It is a universe removed from the elegance, grace and power of Auguste Rodin’s “The Thinker,” a copy of which can be found across state in Philadelphia’s Rodin Museum.
If it weren’t for the racial offense the Foster statue generates, thanks to the presence of the songwriter’s subordinate muse “Uncle Ned,” it would be about as interesting as the pigeon guano that periodically covers it.
Still, the Stephen Foster statue has managed to occupy prime public space in this city since 1900. (It was moved to the Oakland location in 1944.) It has survived debates and protests, along with overwhelming public indifference. People who have lived here for decades have insisted they never noticed it until it was pointed out to them. Can there be a worse fate for a work of art than yawns and glazed eyes?
But the Pittsburgh Art Commission didn’t recommend banishment of the statue because it is bad art. Presumably, they want it removed for the same reason that most Pittsburghers who are aware of its existence do — it is an anachronism from an age in which black people were only two generations removed from slavery, but still subject to public insults and slanders.
Apologists for the statue would have us believe that Uncle Ned’s presence as Foster’s inspiration doubles as a critique of slavery, an institution that was overthrown 40 years before the statue was erected.
No one should be gullible enough to believe that robber barons like Mellon and Pitcairn were interested in “critiquing” slavery. If anything, the Stephen Foster statue became a de facto monument to Jim Crow, since a metaphorical black man remained in a subservient and well-defined role as a buffoonish entertainer despite “inspiring” Foster.
Besides, if there really was any interest in honoring Uncle Ned and the Negro folk tradition that inspired Foster, they could just as easily have erected a statue to Ned and put Foster at Ned’s feet since that would’ve been a truer representation of the relationship.
Sure, it would’ve been impossible from a design perspective to give Ned any dignity or credit given the attitudes of the times, but turning a songwriter who died penniless into Pittsburgh’s Great White Father was about as hollow an exercise in civic idolatry as one could imagine.
For its part, the Foster statue occupies an uncomfortable space between the old and new Pittsburgh that we’re always attempting to reconcile. We aspire to be better than the community that has tolerated so many inequities over the decades that this statue, no matter how offensive, couldn’t begin to represent in its entirety.
Until recently, the critical consensus was to hold on to a statue that insulted a large swatch of the population simply because it honored a Pittsburgher and was “historic.”
For me, the question has always been: How does a community that fancies itself a “city of the future” continue to honor a gift imposed on it by the “smartest” minds of the 19th century? This tension defines modern Pittsburgh.
Assuming Mayor Bill Peduto accepts the recommendation of the Art Commission and moves Stephen Foster to an as yet undisclosed location, we should begin thinking of a more suitable replacement for the 21st century.
I join the many Pittsburghers who would like a statue of August Wilson to be created to fill that honored space off that heavily trafficked corridor of learning on Forbes between the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University. A statue of a man who, as an autodidact truant, passed the Stephen Foster statue every day on his way to the Carnegie Library isn’t likely to embarrass us 100 years from now, like its predecessor.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.