Shortly after midnight on Sunday morning, O.J. Simpson, the former king of tabloid sensationalism, emerged from Lovelock Correctional Center in Nevada after nine years. When he entered prison at the dawn of the Obama era, Simpson was still a creature of deep fascination in the culture, occupying more than his fair share of column inches in both mainstream newspapers and tabloids years after the double murder trial that would forever define him.
In many ways, O.J. Simpson’s arrest and conviction for the armed robbery of Las Vegas sports memorabilia dealers was a welcome coincidence for Barack Obama. The 44th president eschewed drama with a ferocity surpassed only by his successor, who embraces drama unapologetically.
O.J. Simpson leaving prison late at night to avoid a media scrum just as Donald Trump, a longtime rival for tabloid infamy, has ascended to the presidency is an example of the kind of coincidence that makes America a land of nearly limitless ironies. O.J. Simpson’s return at a time of peak surrealism in America ushered in by the Trump presidency makes sense in a way that would not have resonated during the Obama years. He’s the perfect citizen for these times.
When he was sentenced to prison for the robbery in Las Vegas, the majority of African-Americans were still willing to give Simpson the benefit of the doubt for murdering ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ron Goldman. Blacks disproportionately agreed with the “not guilty” verdict that freed Simpson during his double homicide trial the decade before. It was not because of any widespread belief he wasn’t capable of doing it, but more out of a cynical despair.
Supporting O.J. Simpson became the expression of an irrational desire for “victory” against a biased criminal justice system, even if it undermined confidence in the jury system in the long run and set a likely murderer free. These days, both blacks and whites agree that O.J. Simpson is most likely guilty of the double homicide and that the “not guilty” verdict that felt so good in October 1995 was a travesty of justice with a dark, karmic legacy.
African-Americans are now acutely aware that the Simpson verdict contributed to the willingness of all-white or nearly all-white juries to exonerate an unstable vigilante like George Zimmerman for killing Trayvon Martin. The dozens of grand juries across the country that have refused to indict cops for killing unarmed black men and boys have become the moral doppelgangers of the Simpson jury.
Read More
Meanwhile, O.J. Simpson is re-entering American life at a fascinating time in our history. The fact that most of us consider him guilty is, in many ways, the collateral damage of the Black Lives Matter movement constantly calling attention to the real martyrs who have replaced fake martyrs like O.J. Simpson. There’s not a whole lot of sympathy for rich guys who are “conveniently black” only when they get into trouble.
Simpson will quickly discover that America has changed on many fronts since he has been gone, although some elements — like mass shootings by deranged individuals with access to guns — will be depressingly familiar.
When O.J. went to prison, Bill Cosby was still a respected comic icon and TV father. Now that more than 50 women have come forward to accuse him of sexually assaulting them, Mr. Cosby has eclipsed O.J. as America’s least popular black guy. That will take some getting used to if you’re as used to being front- page tabloid fodder as O.J. Simpson is.
Nine years ago, a protesting quarterback like Colin Kaepernick would’ve been impossible to imagine. For decades, the National Football League has been a bastion of patriotic conformity, where dedication to the paycheck papered over any qualms about societal ills outside of the arena. Now the NFL is in full revolt against the president of the United States. Whoever wins the Super Bowl in 2018 will probably skip a visit to the White House.
Before O.J. went to prison, there had been murmurs and even scientific evidence about the toll that high-collision football takes on the brain, but not a lot of action. Now it has reached the point where the players themselves won’t allow their sons to play the game.
During his infamous Alabama speech on Sept. 22, Mr. Trump complained that football was being “ruined” by rules that limit head injuries. It’s a notion that is completely contrary to the science about chronic traumatic encephalopathy and athlete safety. It is widely assumed that O.J. Simpson also suffers from undiagnosed CTE, but there’s no way of knowing until his brain is examined after his death.
So, O.J. Simpson returns at a time when football is at the center of national debate and a fellow celebrity whose 1993 wedding he attended is now president of the United States. Six months after that wedding, Nicole and Ron were butchered in Brentwood. If there are second acts in American life, O.J. Simpson hopes “Juice on the Loose II” isn’t as bad as every other inevitable sequel.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.