In July, HBO announced that “Game of Thrones” showrunners David Benioff and D.B.Weiss’ next project would be set in the contemporary world. “Confederate” will explore what it would mean to live in America if the Confederacy emerged victorious from the Civil War and slavery continued to exist in the states that seceded from the Union.
Wow, what’s not to love about a premise like that? The reaction to the announcement, of course, was far from the chorus of cheers and squeals of delight HBO assumed would greet the unveiling of the next project by the creators of its most popular series ever.
Though not a single script has been written, a series about a victorious Confederacy would surely feature as much human degradation, mass rape and denial of black humanity as the real thing or risk being called a whitewash by its legion of critics, right?
Any attempt to make modern American slavery appear more genteel in comparison to the version actually enshrined in our dark and violent history would meet furious pushback from anyone with a modicum of conscience and historical awareness.
It’s already hard to imagine the entertainment value of such non-stop misery, much less a narrative framework that creates the usual space for white people on the show (and in the audience) to maintain any sense of innocence through the end credits. The deniability of white privilege would be impossible in a scenario where slavery is a daily reality, regardless of where your white ancestors come from.
A modern Confederacy would be a nation of psychotics whose devotion to its antebellum forbearers would make it an international pariah. In such a world, the Confederacy probably would have sided with the Axis in World War II, since Hitler’s values are Confederate values imposed on European Jewry.
Because the idea of “Confederacy” ignited a torrent of bad press, HBO attempted to control the furor by announcing that the married writer-producers Malcolm Spellman (“Empire”) and Nichelle Tramble Spellman (“The Good Wife”) will be writing and producing the show with Benioff and Weiss.
Because the Spellmans are black, HBO is hoping their presence on the project will signal to skeptical critics that things will only be allowed to get so racist before a black person with actual clout raises an objection. But the premise of the series is already racially problematic enough to make one wonder what the black folks overseeing “Confederacy” consider a red line.
And how are they going to get black American actors to appear in something like this? This is probably the one instance in which American-born blacks will gladly defer to their Afro-Anglo competitors in Hollywood instead of complaining about how they steal their roles.
Meanwhile, Amazon, the studio that brought us the adaptation of Philip K.Dick’s “Man in a High Castle” — an alternative history in which the Nazis and Japanese occupy America — announced that “Black America,” a new series by producer Will Packer and “Boondocks” creator Aaron McGruder, has been in the works for a year.
“Black America” asks what would have happened had Louisiana, Alabama and Mississippi been given to the newly freed slaves as reparations after the Civil War. The black-ruled territory now called New Colonia is successful and modern, but has an uneasy relationship with America, which is faltering in comparison. It must also constantly put down coup attempts by seditious descendants of former slave owners.
Like “Confederate,” this drama takes place in the modern world, but doesn’t feature a single slave. Folks who object to the HBO drama are much more positive about “Black America” because it is guaranteed not to be a deep dive into black pain by white saviors. It will be the kind of show black people have always craved — one in which we actually have a future that doesn’t entail singing the blues.
The problem with HBO’s “Confederate” sight unseen is that it will operate as a sick fantasy for millions of viewers who do crave a different ending to the Civil War.
When Hollywood executives look at black people, they see social problems, tap dancers, sneaker pitchmen, gangbangers, single moms, prison orange, comedians, fast-food customers, pimps, crackheads, funny sidekicks and slavery.
What Hollywood consistently refuses to see is the full humanity of black people. In a million years, it would never occur to the typical studio executive who green-lights a show like “Confederate” to come up with a half-hour show as difficult to categorize and as nuanced about the black experience as Donald Glover’s “Atlanta” on FX. It takes a creative juggernaut of Mr. Glover’s stature to even walk something that odd into a studio for consideration.
Here’s a counterfactual scenario for you: Imagine a Hollywood where television shows and movies aren’t run through the strainer of studio executives’ limited class, racial, gender and ideological biases. Imagine a Hollywood where diverse players are always at the table and stupid ideas die on the vine. Having a hard time imaging such a place? Me, too.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.