May 29 was the 100th anniversary of President John Fitzgerald Kennedy’s birth. Had he not been assassinated on Nov. 22, 1963, it isn’t likely he would have beaten the brutal odds of the actuarial table to be alive to see his 100th birthday, anyway.
Though he radiated youthful energy, JFK was a physical wreck beset by intestinal complaints, adrenal problems, fevers, headaches and chronic back pain. Because he died at the relatively young age of 46, we didn’t get to see him limp into his 70s and 80s with once undisclosed ailments like his Addison’s disease.
Perhaps he would have retained the the rugged good looks of his 40s even if he had gained weight like his younger brother, Teddy, another Kennedy princeling who succumbed to the various temptations at Hyannis Port while growing up.
It’s a fascinating exercise to imagine the kind of country America would’ve been without the death of JFK to wake us from the somnambulance of the 1950s. It was his martyrdom in Dallas that ushered in a decade of social and political upheaval unrivaled since the Civil War.
Who knows if JFK could have achieved a second term in 1964. He was a popular enough president to have pulled it off, though. Like Lyndon Baines Johnson, who actually had the honor of burying Arizona Sen. Barry Goldwater in an electoral and popular vote landslide in 1964, he would’ve become an increasingly unpopular president if our entanglement in Vietnam continued unabated.
No one would argue that JFK had the legislative chops of his vice president who shepherded civil rights legislation through an often hostile Congress after the president’s death.
Had JFK lived, he would’ve gotten both the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act through with LBJ’s help and a promise to endorse his run for president in 1968. Most of the planks of LBJ’s Great Society programs, including the war on hunger, would’ve been put in place after he beat Richard Nixon for the White House.
Assuming there was a real troop drawdown in southeast Asia, much of the political turbulence of that year would’ve been dissipated, though protests against racial discrimination would’ve continued.
Imagine 1968 as the last year of JFK’s second term with LBJ a lock to follow him. Given that level of voter confidence, it’s entirely possible to conceive of JFK dismissing J. Edgar Hoover at the FBI after a four decades of domestic surveillance that compromised civil rights leaders like Martin Luther King and anyone Hoover suspected of being “UnAmerican.”
Perhaps firing Hoover and installing, say, Attorney General Robert Kennedy as FBI director as one final act of nepotism would’ve ensured that a plot to kill MLK would’ve been detected and stopped long before Memphis.
With a decade-long term as FBI director to keep him busy, RFK would not have challenged his brother’s vice president for the Democratic presidential nomination. A dynasty wary America wouldn’t have wanted another Kennedy in the White House so soon after JFK’s second term.
And then there would be the celebrations around the moon landing on July 20, 1969, JFK’s first year out of office. It was the fulfillment of his greatest challenge to America to send men to the moon and bring them back “not because it is easy, but because it is hard.”
With JFK, MLK and RFK still on the scene and Vietnam a nationalistic struggle left to the Vietnamese to sort out, there probably would’ve been less incentive for a counterculture to challenge the status quo. A masterpiece like the Beatles’ “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band,” released 50 years ago this month, made popular culture even more utopian, but without an entrenched establishment committed to stupid wars and social conformity to rage against, would it have found as big an audience?
Would Jimi Hendrix’s electrifying and subversive performance of “The Star-Spangled Banner” at Woodstock in 1969 have resonated as much if JFK, MLK and RFK were still alive? Would there have even been a Woodstock without a growing anti-war movement supplying tens of thousands of supple young bodies to frolic in the sun and mud?
But this counterfactual spitballing doesn’t amount to anything, really. The reality is that JFK was laid to rest 54 years ago on a cold November day. Still, many of us still weep for the president we lost and for the world that might’ve been had John F. Kennedy been given more than a thousand days to change America for the better.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.