When Bill Cosby goes on trial in June for three counts of felony aggravated indecent assault, he will not take the stand in his own defense. A jury brought in from Allegheny County won’t see the formerly sharp monologist, now legally blind from the ravages of glaucoma, grasping for words to explain his predicament.
The former comedy star told Sirius-XM radio this week that his lawyers feared what could happen to him under cross-examination. It feels like a lifetime since he starred in those lovable Jell-O Pudding ads or projected boardroom gravitas as E.F. Hutton’s main pitchman.
Even if found not guilty by a jury of his peers, the 79-year-old comedian will never reclaim the affection America once had for him. At the height of the Ronald Reagan era, Mr. Cosby was universally lauded as our nation’s most beloved father figure.
Since those days, scores of women have come forward to accuse Mr. Cosby of either drugging them as a prelude to nonconsensual sex or attempting to drug them for that purpose. Still, he is not on trial for those 60-plus assaults, thanks to the statute of limitations. Next month, Mr. Cosby will face only one accuser with whom he previously reached a financial settlement.
After allowing for the possibility that a minority of accusers could be copycats, the deluge of sexual assault complaints spread over five decades can’t all be fake. None of his accusers is making a claim for part of his fortune as recompense for pain and suffering as far as I know.
Bill Cosby’s rich comedic legacy can’t be reduced completely to ashes no matter what the verdict is next month — nor should it. It is appropriate to acknowledge the great things he’s done as a cultural trailblazer, for civil rights and as a philanthropist. But it is also necessary to come to grips with why his narrative has been rendered vastly more problematic. If he’s found guilty, his criminality is also a part of his legacy that must be dealt with.
Among African-Americans who aren’t old enough to remember Bill Cosby in his prime, there’s more than a bit of schadenfreude at work when it comes to the fall of America’s favorite dad. Mr. Cosby offended millions of young blacks who preferred Biggie and Tupac to Fat Albert and “Mush Mouth” when he began leaning a little too much on an intellectually discredited brand of respectability politics that singled out poorer African-Americans for a scolding — while leaving wealthier blacks and all classes of whites unscathed. In retrospect, his hypocrisy is especially galling given the fact that he was being accused, even then, of sex crimes.
In a hilarious stand-up routine, comedian Eddie Murphy described how Mr. Cosby once called to chastise him about all of the cursing he did on stage. Mr. Cosby’s then teenage son, Ennis, had just returned from an Eddie Murphy show in the wee hours of the morning. He was downcast and complained about all the curse words “he had never heard before” in Mr. Murphy’s act. He was deeply offended.
In the bit, Mr. Murphy imitates Mr. Cosby perfectly. There is no hint that he knows about any of the rumors that were already swirling around Mr. Cosby in the early 1980s when he recorded that routine.
Still, the routine illustrates the pomposity and hypocrisy of Bill Cosby as a moral arbiter of anything. Somewhat rattled by Mr. Cosby’s call, Eddie Murphy sought out Richard Pryor, the dean of stand-up comics, to get his take on the call. According to Mr. Murphy, Pryor asked him a few questions along the lines of: Do people laugh when you curse and are the jokes funny?
When Mr. Murphy answered yes to all of his questions, he mimicked Richard Pryor’s incredulous voice perfectly: “Next time you talk to Bill, tell him I said to have a Coke and a smile and to shut the [expletive] up.”
Bill Cosby’s Horatio Alger myth, once so compelling when he was on top of the world, has morphed into a dark tragedy about celebrity presumption and exploitation. He knew in his heart he was a hypocrite for preaching to the “black underclass” about how they could improve themselves morally when he was an even bigger sexual libertine than the youth he regularly lambasted for wearing sagging pants.
The respectability politics Mr. Cosby espoused, to the delight of conservative audiences everywhere, turned out to be fraudulent and non-applicable to his own life. That’s why there is very little sympathy for him among younger African-Americans who cheered heartily when millennial comic Hannibal Buress made a punchline of Mr. Cosby’s long-rumored habit of drugging and violating women.
Mr. Buress’ 2014 stand-up routine suddenly gave the culture permission to hold celebrities like Bill Cosby to the same standard as everyone else.
The fact that Mr. Cosby didn’t sue Mr. Buress for defamation was telling. Other young comedians followed Mr. Buress’ lead and ripped into Mr. Cosby with abandon. The era of granting automatic passes to black celebrities, like O.J. Simpson, had passed. The result of such radical democratization was that Mr. Cosby, for all of his wealth and influence, became just another old black guy full of advice about how people he really didn’t relate to should be living their lives.
Now Bill Cosby is about to go on trial for his life. He’d better hope that no one from the generation he once expressed contempt for will be tempted to answer the call for jury duty.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @TonyNormanPG.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.