Americans are mostly ambivalent about free speech. They’re generally for it when someone else’s ox is being gored and less inclined to tolerate it when it is the other way around.

Even the Founding Fathers who enshrined freedom of speech in the U.S. Constitution weren’t above jailing a newspaper editor or two for sedition and insufficient respect for George Washington.

Not to make too glib a comparison between Washington and Donald Trump, but the current president was not the first to suggest toughening the libel laws to clamp down on press freedom. The loathing Washington felt for Thomas Paine, his former friend and Revolutionary War ally, toward the end of his final term was rooted in the pamphleteer’s willingness to excoriate him in print.

In 1964, the campus of the University of California-Berkeley erupted as students protested for free speech and academic freedom. Those mostly young liberals were opposed by conservatives alarmed by their uniform opposition to the Vietnam War and support for civil rights.

Advertise with us

Right-wingers who hated the Free Speech Movement of the 1960s now embrace that legacy while denouncing the liberal student activism that prevented Ann Coulter from speaking at UC Berkeley last week. Sure, it’s indicative of rank hypocrisy and opportunism, but it also highlights what even many liberals consider a growing hostility to freedom of expression on college and university campuses across the country.

Still, one can suffer a serious bout of whiplash watching conservatives administer a beatdown to campus “snowflakes” at UC Berkeley for opposing Ms. Coulter’s and Milo Yiannopoulos’ right to speak even as those same conservatives threaten boycotts and a defunding of the school because Sunsara Taylor of the Revolutionary Communist Party got to make a speech at the same campus this week.

That’s not to say liberals are covering themselves with First Amendment glory these days, either. The contretemps over The New York Times’ newly hired conservative columnist Bret Stephens is nothing short of embarrassing.

Lots of liberals have threatened to cancel their subscriptions to the Times (although there’s little evidence of massive follow-through) because the paper has hired a columnist many believe to be a climate change denialist.

Mr. Stephens, formerly of the very conservative Wall Street Journal’s editorial page, penned a debut column that attempted to put his thinking on climate change into context, but it only generated more rage and suspicion. His column wasn’t remotely persuasive, but it was easy enough to move on to more enlightening pieces on the same page that day. That’s the beauty of a forum like the Times — great ideas push out the bad ones.

Advertise with us

The fact that Mr. Stephens has a platform to write things that will offend the paper’s core readership shouldn’t automatically disqualify him, especially given the difficulty of finding an American conservative that agrees that climate change is more than an assault on capitalism.

Liberal threats to boycott The New York Times over the hiring of one columnist who flirts with heterodox ideas from the perspective of liberalism is ridiculous. The Times is one of four or five newspapers in America with the resources to cover the Trump presidency with the scrutiny and skepticism it deserves. That really should count for something, no matter how offended one is by Mr. Stephens’ column.

Late-night comic Stephen Colbert has been taking a beating on social media thanks to a fiery opening monologue on Monday in which he made a graphic description of Mr. Trump’s relationship to Russian President Vladimir Putin that can’t be repeated in a family newspaper or website.

A conservative attempt to mimic the social media efforts that contributed to Bill O’Reilly’s firing from Fox News was launched with the clumsy and completely ineffectual #FireColbert hashtag.

A defiant Mr. Colbert has refused to apologize but did concede he would not, if he had to do it over again, use a crude image that many gay people consider homophobic.

Advertise with us

Fox News’ Sean Hannity, who is no Colbert fan, also ridiculed the #FireColbert campaign, but co-signed the notion that those who don’t like the late-night comic’s show should simply change the channel — a surprisingly lucid and mature answer coming from him.

Even as I write this, I’m acutely aware that anyone who has read me long enough knows I’m not a free speech absolutist. If a campus political organization wants to invite, say, Holocaust deniers, apologists for slavery, the American Nazi Party or the Westboro Baptist Church to rally on the university quad, I would have a problem with that. People of the ilk of Coulter, Yiannopoulos and even “The Bell Curve” author Charles Murray have execrable ideas that should be confronted during raucous Q&A’s after their speeches.

Meanwhile, whatever happened to that great American pastime called heckling?

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.