For those keeping score after 152 years, Monday was Confederate Memorial Day. In Alabama and Mississippi, state and government offices were closed in observance of the Confederacy’s loss.
I don’t know if similar state-sanctioned commemorations happen in other countries, but I doubt it. Germans don’t “celebrate” their May 7, 1945, surrender to the Allies. With the exception of a few hundred dead-enders on the fascist fringe, Germans don’t wax nostalgic over how “orderly” society was under the Nazis.
You won’t catch many Germans lobbying for the return of the swastika or other symbols of the Third Reich, either. There are laws against that, even in Europe’s largest democracy.
But here in America, bemoaning “The War of Northern Aggression,” as it is known by those most unhappy with the outcome, is what large swaths of our citizens do. For now, the Civil War continues to be the ghost that haunts the attic of our civic discourse.
At least schools remain open on Confederate Memorial Day, giving educators a chance to provide some context for the controversies that have swirled in their region for six generations.
History teachers in the South are always on the front line negotiating the tricky territory between regional self-esteem and historical truth.
It’s not easy explaining to the descendants of the losing side why their ancestors’ efforts to defend states’ rights was morally and militarily trumped by the Union’s effort to end slavery — especially when they don’t necessarily believe the Civil War was “about” slavery.
It’s going to take a multigenerational effort to explain to many Southerners why 13 states fighting for the right to impose racial tyranny and ownership on blacks in the name of states’ rights was a profoundly evil thing.
Those who insist that the Civil War barely concerned itself with slavery per se because most Confederate soldiers weren’t slave owners and most Union soldiers weren’t fighting to abolish that institution are conveniently ignoring how mass conscription operates.
The motives of the soldiers and their personal politics don’t matter once the bugle blows and the banners start flapping in the bloody breeze. They have their orders and the morality of the war rarely figures into the equation.
It may be that only the generals and their superiors in the military and civilian high command have a clear idea what the conflict is really “about.”
Ask a soldier who has done multiple tours of Afghanistan or Iraq what those wars are about and you’re likely to get stares of incomprehension followed by a long string of obscenities. There’s never high-minded reasons for why young people who have never met try to kill each other in battle. Why should the Civil War be any different?
The tragedy of the Civil War continues to resonate in our own time because we’ve never wrestled honestly with its complex legacy, its underlying cause or its terrible aftermath. National soul searching has been replaced by moral evasion and gross nostalgia for a “Lost Cause” championed by those on the losing side.
On Monday, the city of New Orleans began removing four statues throughout its well-travelled historical districts commemorating the Confederacy’s heroes and its sympathizers.
The first monument to be dismantled under cover of early morning darkness was the offensive “Crescent City White League” obelisk erected in 1874 to honor the racist mob that fought one of the first racially integrated police forces in the country. When I saw that obelisk with my own eyes more than a decade ago during a visit to New Orleans, I thought I was losing my mind. Only in America could wanton cop killers get an obelisk in their honor just because they killed black people. How was it that such an outrageous symbol of racial intransigence was still standing?
Next up for removal from places of prominence if they haven’t been removed already include the bronze statue of Robert E. Lee, a monument to the Confederacy’s president Jefferson Davis and Confederate general P.G.T. Beauregard.
All of the monuments were erected decades after the Civil War ended by Confederate dead-enders who wanted to show the victorious North that they were bloodied, but unbowed by the war’s humiliating end. They were determined to reimpose the racial order they once enjoyed, but under another name — Jim Crow.
So there was much gnashing of teeth about the removal of the monuments Monday, but as usual, much of it happened in a historical vacuum devoid of even a modicum of context. There was much boo hoo-ing regarding the “lack of discussion” about where the monuments will finally end up — whether in museums or warehoused out of sight.
That’s a legitimate concern. Like them or not, those monuments have accrued historical value even from their negative history. They should be preserved and clearly labeled as discredited symbols of a lost and pathetic time in American history. Maybe Confederate Memorial Day will join them next year on the scrap heap of history.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @TonyNormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.