Two weeks ago, I caught Nate Parker’s “The Birth of a Nation” at a morning press screening. Sitting in the dark for nearly two hours, it was hard to shake the feeling that as undeniably powerful as it is, it isn’t a great film. It’s OK. The most remarkable thing about it is the controversy swirling around the film’s star and director, Mr. Parker.

The acting, particularly Mr. Parker in the lead role as the messianic rebellion leader Nat Turner, is impressive. As the film’s director, Mr. Parker is also responsible for its uneven pacing. While the cinematography is stunning, the dialogue flirts dangerously close to cliche more often than it should.

Still, the film’s ambitions and successes more than make up for its stumbles. While it lacks the emotional resonance of the Oscar award-winning antebellum narrative “12 Years a Slave,” it is as beautifully executed as any film that has come out this year.

“Birth of a Nation” does what every prestige-heavy drama about an unjustly forgotten uprising is supposed to do — it reintroduces audiences to a slice of American history it would rather forget. What it fails to do is be the kind of film someone would want — or need — to see a second time.

Advertise with us

Nevertheless, the pre-release buzz about the film was substantial — yet it came with another, unwelcome form of attention for Mr. Parker. It brought to the surface his 1999 case of sexual assault while a student at Penn State. He had been acquitted at the time, but was tried all over again this year in the court of public opinion.

When Mr. Parker shot the film about one of America’s deadliest slave insurrections, the 1999 case was dormant. Consequently, the close-ups of his face in the film show no hint of the inner turmoil of a man wrestling with questions of his own complicity in an act of sexual violence dramatized in his film.

It’s conceivable that when he was shooting the movie, he’d forgotten all about his trial and acquittal as he drilled down into the drama of Nat Turner. In the film, Turner is driven to murder every slave owner who crossed his path after his wife, a fellow slave, was raped (though the historical record attributes his rebellion to religious visions).

There was no cognitive dissonance as he played the role of the avenging husband/abolitionist liberator because he had successfully compartmentalized the part of his life that contained the trial. The rape he was once accused and exonerated of was in the past — the same past that Faulkner insisted was never dead, and “not even past.”

These days, Mr. Parker is confronted with his past everywhere he turns because his past was never dead. The situation he now finds himself in could potentially spark a boycott that endangers the film’s Oscar prospects. Public intellectuals, critics and ordinary moviegoers agonize about the ethics of “supporting” Nate Parker’s artistic ventures given the seriousness of the allegation once filed against him.

Advertise with us

For his part, Mr. Parker is quick to remind the world that he was exonerated and that from his perspective the charge was always bogus. Unfortunately, the woman who accused him took her own life in 2012. Mr. Parker has expressed deep sorrow about that and for anything he may have done to contribute to her deep unhappiness with life. He knows the unidentified woman’s death is just another nail in the coffin that was once his fabled Hollywood rag-to-riches story. He now knows the past will never be done with him, even in the unlikely event he makes dozens of films like Woody Allen and Roman Polanski, two established filmmakers who had to navigate molestation allegations (Allen) and rape charges (Polanski). Both continue to be nominated for and win Oscars.

In a normal year, “Birth of a Nation” would be a shoo-in for best picture Oscar consideration, but this is not an ordinary year thanks to the resurrection of the allegations against Mr. Parker. The decision to see or not see “Birth of a Nation” given the controversy surrounding the filmmaker is one people across the nation are sincerely wrestling with because their consciences compel them to do so.

Personally, I think it would be a tragedy if “Birth of a Nation” was Nate Parker’s last film. He is an immensely talented filmmaker who was implicated in a terrible crime and exonerated of long before his Hollywood career began. I’m not saying that every artist has to be Rimbaud, Louis-Ferdinand Celine or Oscar Wilde, but artists should be allowed to have a past, even a dark one, that informs their art and enlightens us. Some of the guiltiest artists who have ever lived have enriched civilization with their words, music, paintings and performances.

If the new standard is that only the most sinless of artists can expect an audience, then we should prepare ourselves for an era of dull propagandists who will always affirm and never challenge our morality or our complacency.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.