A fascinating factoid about beloved Pope John XXIII concerns his choice of papal moniker in 1958. There hadn’t been a John since Antipope John XXIII sullied the name during a disputed papacy (1410-1415) that ended with his removal for heresy, simony and immorality. To clean up the record, Angelo Roncalli picked the same name for a belated historical do-over.

Something similar motivated Nate Parker’s title selection for his blistering biopic of rebel slave leader Nat Turner: as an antidote to the white racism of D.W. Griffith’s 1915 epic, “The Birth of a Nation.”

‘THE BIRTH OF A NATION’

Ratings explained

Advertise with us

Starring: Nate Parker, Armie Hammer, Aja Naomi King.

Rating: R for disturbing violent content, and some brief nudity.

This nativity is of Mr. Parker’s nation — the black one — 30 years before the Civil War in Virginia, where the literate and deeply religious slave Nat becomes a charismatic plantation preacher. That’s a valuable commodity to his financially strapped owner Samuel Turner (Armie Hammer), who accepts a deal to rent Nat out to other slaveholders, to keep their own Africans in line through religion.

The film, from start to finish, is replete with striking scenes and images, from the mind-and-body-numbing drudgery of cotton picking — bright red bloodstains on snow-white fibers — to romanticized weddings and dancing in the slave quarters, interspersed with appalling slave auctions and atrocities witnessed by Nat on his preaching circuit: blacks beaten, chained, gagged, mutilated, lynched.

“Where’s God now?” one asks in despair.

Advertise with us

After the breaking point, Nat orchestrates his revolt in August 1831 — the biggest slave mutiny in U.S. history — in which 60 white Virginians are murdered before a militia force quells the uprising. Fifty black rebels are executed, including Turner. Hundreds of other blacks who took no part in the rebellion were killed by vigilante mobs seeking vengeance.

Despite the controversy surrounding the film because of the 1999 rape allegations against Mr. Parker during his Penn State years, his directorial debut is a powerful one. He’s also the star, of course, as well as producer and co-writer, based on the true story — the words “based on” being a red flag for purists such as myself. A brutal white gang-rape of Nat’s wife Cherry serves as the narrative catalyst for his revolt, but there’s no evidence it happened. The real Turner never even mentioned Cherry in his own writings, which attribute the rebellion to spiritual visions commanding him to take up arms in a holy war.

William Styron’s famously fictionalized “Confessions of Nat Turner” novel (1968) took far greater liberties. To say nothing of Thomas Dixon Jr.’s “The Clansman” (1902), on which Griffith’s hugely successful “The Birth of a Nation” was based.

Griffth’s film was a terribly false recruiting device for the Ku Klux Klan, against which the newly formed NAACP — championing Native Americans and immigrants as well as blacks — organized nationwide protests.

Scholars have continued to praise the Griffith original as a landmark achievement in film history. Mr. Parker argues it relied on “racist propaganda to evoke fear and desperation as a tool to solidify white supremacy. Not only did it motivate the massive resurgence of the terror group KKK and the carnage exacted against people of African descent, it served as foundation of the film industry we know today. I’ve reclaimed this title and repurposed it as a tool to challenge racism in America.”

Advertise with us

In the title role, Mr. Parker (”Ain’t Them Bodies Saints,” “Arbitrage”) is excellent. So are Aja Naomi King as his wife, Esther Scott as his soulful grandma, and Colman Domingo as his friend and fellow warrior Hark. Except for Mr. Hammer — very effective as Nat’s weak, conflicted master — the other white characters all tend to be monsters or drooling mutants, including poor Jackie Earle Haley. That’s a shame.

Even so, this heavy-handed howl of anguish provides disturbing insight into the way opposite sides use the same religion for opposite ends, driving blacks and whites alike to unthinkable violence in the process.

Hard to imagine a more timely and polarizing moral, social, racial agenda. Forget “Django Unchained” or even “12 Years a Slave.” Nat Turner, like John Brown, views himself as an instrument of God’s wrath, not love. His final Stations of the Cross, as Mr. Parker depicts it, are too Gibsonesque (”Passion of the Christ”) for comfort.

But who says, with this history, there’s any real comfort to be found?

Post-Gazette film critic emeritus Barry Paris can be reached at parispg48@aol.com.

Correction, updated Oct. 11, 2016: An earlier version of this review stated that President Woodrow Wilson hailed D.W. Griffith’s 1915 racist film “The Birth of a Nation” as “like writing history with lightning...all so terribly true.” However, the 2013 A. Scott Berg biography “Wilson” disputes President Wilson ever made the comment.