Chris Rock is smart enough to know that even his tough love monologue at this year’s Academy Awards probably won’t change many hearts and minds where it counts — in studio corner offices where deals are brokered and movies are green lit by the same insular executives year after year. Still, something had to be said about the Academy’s appalling lack of diversity on the industry’s biggest night before it could be allowed to continue with its usual orgy of self-congratulation.
“It’s the 88th Academy Awards, which means this whole ‘no black nominees’ thing has happened at least 71 times. OK?” the comic said as the cameras panned strained, smiling faces. Citing 1962 as a likely example, “Black people did not protest. Why? Because we had real things to protest at the time. We were too busy being raped and lynched to care about who won Best Cinematographer. When your grandma is swinging from a tree, it’s really hard to care about Best Documentary Foreign Short.”
With the kind of ruthless insight that made everyone wonder why someone with his reputation for merciless evisceration was picked to emcee, Chris Rock proceeded to place a sharp knife to the neck of his nervously gulping audience. “Is Hollywood racist? You know, that’s a ... You gotta go at that the right way,” he said. “Is it burning-cross racist? No. Is it fetch-me-some-lemonade racist? No. No, no, no. It’s a different type of racist,” he said before delivering the cut: “Hollywood is sorority racist. It’s like, ‘We like you Rhonda, but you’re not Kappa.’ That’s how Hollywood is.”
Comparing Hollywood’s structural racism to the tribalism of campus fraternities and sororities lets the industry off a little too easy, but it does get at the vacuity of the gatekeepers in both cases. Hollywood’s knee-jerk rationalizations for doing such a poor job of hiring across the racial spectrum are legendary and ludicrous.
For instance, foreign markets, especially in Asia, are usually blamed for the excessive whiteness of the industry’s narratives because customers in the world’s emerging movie markets allegedly don’t like seeing non-white faces on the big screen (or even Asian faces, since that group’s numbers are even lower than Hispanics and African-Americans in Hollywood films). Without white actors in the starring and secondary roles, it is difficult to sell films abroad.
Studios are also said to be eager to hire minorities, but finding “qualified” directors, actors, screenwriters, cinematographers, cast directors, editors, producers or anyone of color is almost impossible. The NFL’s Rooney Rule (always interviewing a minority for head coach or senior positions) works in football. But it won’t work in Tinseltown because the industry has always operated on the basis of a strict meritocracy — not nepotism, casting couches or anything resembling gender or racial politics.
Only the best of the best are guaranteed work — and if those who are qualified are overwhelmingly white, well, that’s just how the statistical cookie crumbles. When structural racism is ruled out, only the incompetence of minorities themselves can explain Hollywood’s dismal hiring numbers.
I’m sure the overwhelming success of a minority-dominated musical like “Hamilton,” currently the biggest hit on Broadway by a factor of 10, is furrowing many an experienced brow in Hollywood. After all, the most critically acclaimed musical in decades has no “white” stars and makes no apologies for dragging the Founding Fathers out of their alabaster tombs and reimagining their conflicts as opportunities for dope rhymes and text-heavy battle raps.
Lin-Manuel Miranda, the American-born son of Puerto Rican immigrants who conceived the show and wrote the music, told an interviewer last year that because there are only a few roles on Broadway for someone of his racial background, he had to write his own material. While writing “Hamilton,” Mr. Miranda recruited black, Hispanic and Asian actors to fill the rolls that would have gone exclusively to white actors if casting was left to Hollywood.
Mr. Manuel plays Alexander Hamilton, while Aaron Burr is played by Leslie Odom Jr. Christopher Jackson plays George Washington while Daveed Diggs, the son of a white Jewish mother and black father, plays the Marquis de Lafayette and Thomas Jefferson. King George is played by Jonathan Groff, a white actor, but Eliza Hamilton is played by Phillipa Soo and her sister, Angelica Schuyler, is played by Renee Elise Goldsberry, a black woman. Nothing remotely this radical has ever been attempted in Hollywood for obvious reasons.
It is only a matter of time before “Hamilton” is the subject of a big screen adaptation like every other big Broadway hit. There may be a temptation to follow the formula that works on Broadway, but Hollywood knows better. Sure, these minorities are talented in their own way, but as long as Eddie Redmayne and Cate Blanchett are around, we know we have the ingredients for a worldwide blockbuster that foreign audiences will really love.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @TonyNormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.