Reading the various summaries of the “Study of the Central Intelligence Agency’s Detention and Interrogation Program” over the last few days has been akin to stumbling into the middle of hell as depicted in Hieronymus Bosch’s darkest paintings.
There’s so much taking place in the Dutch master’s paintings that your eyes can barely decide where to settle first. Bird- and fish-headed demons torture the damned in what can only be described as a kaleidoscope of eternal misery.
Every inch of Bosch’s paintings reveals either a soul broken on contraptions actually used in the dungeons of Europe at the time or some fanciful invention the artist believed would look terrifying, illuminated by a backdrop of hell’s crimson light.
When I was a kid, the thing that terrified me most about Hieronymus Bosch’s paintings was how bureaucratic his vision of hell was. Terrible things happen to every human depicted in his paintings, but their damnation is part of a larger network of cruelty and hopelessness that has no real overseer.
If you look closely at his paintings, you notice that no one devil is ever in charge of all the wickedness on display. Hell is depicted as a bureaucracy of the most infernal kind. Every act of inscrutable sadism is carried out with a demonic efficiency that answers to no higher morality. It is never personal. There’s very little malice involved.
Sound familiar?
When I first began reading about the Holocaust in high school, I saw echoes of Hieronymus Bosch in the photographs of the living corpses liberated from the Nazi death camps. The Third Reich’s bureaucratic obsession with cataloging the genocide of European Jewry was indistinguishable, in my mind, from Bosch’s scampering demons.
The number of German officers ultimately held responsible for crimes against humanity at the Nuremberg trials fell far short of accounting for the scale of the catastrophe enacted on their watch.
The ordinary Germans who claimed they “didn’t know” what was being done in their name, but who continued to support their government’s nihilistic war effort, deserved to be in the dock at Nuremberg, too, — and they knew it.
Today, we Americans find ourselves in a similar position to the Germans during World War II. Though the scale of our crime is vastly smaller, it is no less morally perilous.
Through much of the last decade, a great demonic bureaucracy acting in our name has been as busy as Bosch’s devils by inflicting medieval-style torture on a small number of suspected al-Qaida terrorists and plotters. The Senate Intelligence Committee’s accounts of the CIA’s interrogation techniques reveal tactics and a degree of moral obliviousness that would have been familiar to both the Nazis and the devils who ran the Spanish Inquisition.
References in the report to sleep deprivation, forced stress positions, sexual humiliation, waterboarding, freezing prisoners like human popsicles and something called “rectal hydration” reveal the work of a cruelly efficient bureaucracy that had no regard for a higher morality.
For all of their cruelty and efficiency, the interrogations proved mostly ineffective and yielded more lies told under duress than actionable intelligence from the prisoners.
This week, former Vice President Dick Cheney sneered at any notion that the United States engaged in torture and insisted that the report, which he hadn’t read, is a partisan hack job.
“I’d do it again in a minute,” said the man with a bionically enhanced heart. But we all know Mr. Cheney’s moral compass is shaky.
If a Hieronymus Bosch painting were shown to him without captions, he would describe it as his ideal of how a well-functioning national security state operates. No one is accountable for torture in his world.
Secret prisons, harsh interrogations, the deception of Congress, the manipulation of journalists and hiding the truth about torture from the American people all represent a betrayal of our deepest values.
Or maybe they don’t. Maybe we’re the type of nation that considers torture a reasonable antidote to fear. If so, the words on the base of the Statue of Liberty should change to reflect hell’s warning to Dante at the beginning of his journey: “Abandon hope all ye who enter here.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.