Read­ing the var­i­ous sum­ma­ries of the “Study of the Cen­tral In­tel­li­gence Agency’s De­ten­tion and In­ter­ro­ga­tion Pro­gram” over the last few days has been akin to stum­bling into the mid­dle of hell as de­picted in Hi­ero­ny­mus Bosch’s dark­est paint­ings.

There’s so much tak­ing place in the Dutch mas­ter’s paint­ings that your eyes can barely de­cide where to set­tle first. Bird- and fish-headed demons tor­ture the damned in what can only be de­scribed as a ka­lei­do­scope of eter­nal mis­ery.

Every inch of Bosch’s paint­ings re­veals ei­ther a soul bro­ken on con­trap­tions ac­tu­ally used in the dun­geons of Europe at the time or some fan­ci­ful in­ven­tion the art­ist be­lieved would look ter­ri­fy­ing, il­lu­mi­nated by a back­drop of hell’s crim­son light.

When I was a kid, the thing that ter­ri­fied me most about Hi­ero­ny­mus Bosch’s paint­ings was how bu­reau­cratic his vi­sion of hell was. Ter­ri­ble things hap­pen to ev­ery hu­man de­picted in his paint­ings, but their dam­na­tion is part of a larger net­work of cru­elty and hope­less­ness that has no real over­seer.

Advertise with us

If you look closely at his paint­ings, you no­tice that no one devil is ever in charge of all the wick­ed­ness on dis­play. Hell is de­picted as a bu­reau­cracy of the most in­fer­nal kind. Every act of in­scru­ta­ble sa­dism is car­ried out with a de­monic ef­fi­ciency that an­swers to no higher mo­ral­ity. It is never per­sonal. There’s very lit­tle mal­ice in­volved.

Sound fa­mil­iar?

When I first be­gan read­ing about the Ho­lo­caust in high school, I saw echoes of Hi­ero­ny­mus Bosch in the pho­to­graphs of the liv­ing corpses lib­er­ated from the Nazi death camps. The Third Re­ich’s bu­reau­cratic ob­ses­sion with cat­a­log­ing the geno­cide of Euro­pean Jewry was in­dis­tin­guish­able, in my mind, from Bosch’s scam­per­ing demons.

The num­ber of Ger­man of­fi­cers ul­ti­mately held re­spon­si­ble for crimes against hu­man­ity at the Nur­em­berg tri­als fell far short of ac­count­ing for the scale of the ca­tastro­phe en­acted on their watch.

The or­di­nary Ger­mans who claimed they “didn’t know” what was be­ing done in their name, but who con­tin­ued to sup­port their gov­ern­ment’s ni­hi­lis­tic war ef­fort, de­served to be in the dock at Nur­em­berg, too, — and they knew it.

Advertise with us

To­day, we Amer­i­cans find our­selves in a sim­i­lar po­si­tion to the Ger­mans dur­ing World War II. Though the scale of our crime is vastly smaller, it is no less mor­ally per­il­ous.

Through much of the last de­cade, a great de­monic bu­reau­cracy act­ing in our name has been as busy as Bosch’s dev­ils by in­flict­ing me­di­e­val-style tor­ture on a small num­ber of sus­pected al-Qaida ter­ror­ists and plot­ters. The Senate In­tel­li­gence Com­mit­tee’s ac­counts of the CIA’s in­ter­ro­ga­tion tech­niques re­veal tac­tics and a de­gree of moral obliv­i­ous­ness that would have been fa­mil­iar to both the Na­zis and the dev­ils who ran the Spa­nish In­qui­si­tion.

Ref­er­ences in the re­port to sleep depri­va­tion, forced stress po­si­tions, sex­ual hu­mil­i­a­tion, wa­ter­board­ing, freez­ing pris­on­ers like hu­man pop­si­cles and some­thing called “rec­tal hy­dra­tion” re­veal the work of a cru­elly ef­fi­cient bu­reau­cracy that had no re­gard for a higher mo­ral­ity.

For all of their cru­elty and ef­fi­ciency, the in­ter­ro­ga­tions proved mostly in­ef­fec­tive and yielded more lies told un­der du­ress than ac­tion­able in­tel­li­gence from the pris­on­ers.

This week, for­mer Vice Pres­i­dent Dick Cheney sneered at any no­tion that the United States en­gaged in tor­ture and in­sisted that the re­port, which he hadn’t read, is a par­ti­san hack job.

Advertise with us

“I’d do it again in a minute,” said the man with a bi­on­i­cally en­hanced heart. But we all know Mr. Cheney’s moral com­pass is shaky.

If a Hi­ero­ny­mus Bosch paint­ing were shown to him with­out cap­tions, he would de­scribe it as his ideal of how a well-func­tion­ing na­tional se­cu­rity state op­er­ates. No one is ac­count­able for tor­ture in his world.

Se­cret pris­ons, harsh in­ter­ro­ga­tions, the de­cep­tion of Con­gress, the ma­nip­u­la­tion of jour­nal­ists and hid­ing the truth about tor­ture from the Amer­i­can peo­ple all rep­resent a be­trayal of our deep­est val­ues.

Or maybe they don’t. Maybe we’re the type of na­tion that con­sid­ers tor­ture a rea­son­able an­ti­dote to fear. If so, the words on the base of the Statue of Lib­erty should change to re­flect hell’s warn­ing to Dante at the be­gin­ning of his jour­ney: “Aban­don hope all ye who en­ter here.”