Last week, Rolling Stone did the journalistic equivalent of a rat abandoning a sinking ship — minus the rat’s dignity.
The ship in this case was the magazine’s bombshell reporting on an alleged gang rape of a first-year student, identified only as “Jackie,” at a University of Virginia fraternity house in 2012.
Jackie’s original account includes details about when and where the assault reportedly took place, some of the nicknames of her seven rapists, a running tally of the violence inflicted on her and an unflinching description of the blood shed during a three-hour session she miraculously survived.
The story landed on the university’s campus like an atom bomb when it was published last month. Because UVA was still reeling from the murder of a student earlier in the semester and accusations that it was slow to act on past sexual assault claims, it leapt into action.
Though only one fraternity — Phi Kappa Psi — was implicated in reporter Sabrina Rubin Erdely’s story, UVA suspended all fraternity and sorority activity on campus until January, pending an investigation.
Meanwhile, Ms. Erdely’s blockbuster failed to pass elementary standards of journalism. Major elements of her story dissolved under the most cursory inspection. Rolling Stone later admitted that Jackie discouraged Ms. Erdely from contacting her assailants for their version of events, thus limiting the magazine to a single source for its most explosive allegations.
Before publication, Jackie tried to extricate herself from the story completely, but the reporter insisted that Rolling Stone would go forward with or without her cooperation. In an ironic twist, Jackie continued cooperating but insisted on “fact-checking” everything written about her for accuracy.
After detailed reporting by the Washington Post effectively put a stake in the heart of Ms. Erdely’s story, Rolling Stone published a buck-passing mea culpa:
“In the face of new information, there now appear to be discrepancies in Jackie’s account, and we have come to the conclusion that our trust in her was misplaced. We were trying to be sensitive to the unfair shame and humiliation many women feel after a sexual assault and now regret the decision to not contact the alleged assaulters to get their account. We are taking this seriously and apologize to anyone who was affected by the story.”
Someone obviously got to managing editor Will Dana and explained that it was not a good idea to blame Jackie for Rolling Stone’s own bad journalism, since it was at fault for publishing her unverified story in the first place. “These mistakes are on Rolling Stone, not on Jackie,” he later conceded in one of the great journalistic understatements of the 21st century.
There’s been a lot of gnashing of teeth since Rolling Stone’s story collapsed. Well-meaning critics suggest that the magazine’s editorial sloppiness will make it harder for future victims of sexual assault to come forward. This is nonsense.
There’s no doubt that sexual assault is a big problem on college campuses, as well as in the military. Enough women — and increasingly, men — come forward with verifiable testimonies every day. Every American personally knows someone — more likely multiple people — who has been sexually assaulted. This isn’t even debatable.
But it’s troubling that the media insist on treating victims of sexual assault as if they belong to a rarefied category of crime that prevents their names from ever being used. This willful disregard for truth breeds inevitable journalistic abuses like those committed by Rolling Stone.
Jackie’s alleged rapists weren’t named, but a fraternity that has no members who fit her description was punished. The real rapists, if they exist, will escape justice because Jackie only agreed to confront them in the court of public opinion — not in an actual court of law.
Rape is not about sex, so trying to shield victims from “shame” makes no sense. Rape is about someone exerting power over other humans and attempting to decimate them at the most intimate level possible. It’s not just an assault against an individual; it is a crime against society. Society has a more compelling interest in a rapist getting caught than an individual has a right to privacy.
Just as no one feels “shame” after they’ve been robbed, there should be no misplaced feelings of shame after sexual assault. If you lived through it and can identify your assailant, then you have a duty to do so. We in the media should get beyond the Victorian mentality that insists sexual assault is the one crime that dare not speak the victim’s name.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.