President Bush weighed in on another education issue this week, saying that schools should teach something called "intelligent design" alongside the theory of evolution to explain the origins of life.
Now, I happen to be a big fan of intelligent design. In fact, I'd like to see a lot more of it in this administration. Unfortunately, it's too late for an intelligent design to the war in Iraq, based as it was on a series of mistaken, if not invented, premises. But hope springs eternal for some sign of intelligence in other areas of national import, like homeland security, health care, trade and foreign policy.
But back to the schools. The theory of evolution, of course, is based on Charles Darwin's research in the mid-1800s, using evidence that plants and animals developed over time through slight variations in successive generations, and that natural selection determines which forms survive.
Our language has a word for this kind of systematized information derived from observation, study and experimentation. It's called "science." Science, as it happens, is not always exact; it is, however, always evolving as new ideas, discoveries and techniques come to the fore.
The sometimes unsettled nature of this kind of inquiry has made science a very controversial subject right now, one that Bush considers far too important to be left to scientists.
This is why he put the oil industry in charge of energy and environmental policy. If it were up to scientists working in the interest of the nation's health, we might have to increase fuel efficiency, cut way down on pollution and reverse global warming. This way is so much easier.
Intelligent design, on the other hand, holds that life is so complex, it has to have been created by a supernatural mastermind, i.e., God, because there's no other explanation. But here we come to a couple of sticking points. Our language has a word for a belief system based on the divine. It's called "religion." And our country has a word for the teaching of religion in public schools. It's called "unconstitutional."
Or used to be. A number of states have been looking for ways to allow, or even mandate, the teaching of intelligent design. The former includes Pennsylvania, home of the country's most bloated and overpaid legislature, which hasn't been able to solve our property tax dilemma or public transit woes, raise the minimum wage or address the 1.3 million residents lacking health insurance. But this they can find time to meddle in. No wonder they think they deserve a 16 percent to 34 percent raise disguised as "unvouchered expenses." As long as they're making trouble, they can at least claim to be doing something.
Anyway, this supernatural part is where intelligent design gets interesting. Proponents are careful not to come right out and name God as the designer because that would make intelligent design look a bit too much like Creationism, the pseudo-science based on a literal interpretation of the Biblical stories in Genesis. An attempt to teach Creationism in the public schools would be tougher to get past the gatekeepers than the subterfuge that is intelligent design.
By skirting the issue of who the designer might be, intelligent designers can claim immunization against First Amendment concerns. "Hey," they can say, "we totally respect everyone's right to fill in that blank however they like! If you want to believe it's a giant spidery-looking thing from the planet Zxaculon, we're not going to argue! No constitutional issues here, nosiree!"
Now, as a person of certain religious beliefs myself, I have to say that I see no inherent conflict between evolution and intelligent design. There's no reason God couldn't have created the system by which organisms evolve over time. As a matter of fact, the two could co-exist quite peacefully.
But, and this is a big BUT, that doesn't make intelligent design science. "Lack of any other explanation" is not evidence of anything -- except, perhaps, in some circumstances, a lack of imagination.
But you know what? If we're going to open the door to intelligent design, we ought to open it all the way. Let's begin with Scientology. Advanced practitioners should be invited to explain that 75 million years ago, the cosmic ruler Xenu paralyzed billions of people in our galaxy, stacked them in volcanoes and destroyed their bodies with H-bombs, creating traumatized alien spirits that invade human bodies today.
I mean, if they call it Scientology, it must be science, right? And I can't think of any other explanation for Tom Cruise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.