It is hard to comprehend why anyone thought John Lennon’s “Imagine” was an appropriate musical tribute to former First Lady Rosalynn Carter, a devout Baptist, but long before that bizarre moment at her memorial service Tuesday, I had already planned to use this day to urge all my Jewish and Christian friends and readers:
Run toward your faith. No matter what doubts or hurts you harbor, run toward faith with open arms, mind and heart.
Advent begins this Sunday and Hanukkah next Thursday, and there’s no easier time of year to dig into the riches of religious ritual and community. At no point in my lifetime, not even 9/11, has doing so seemed so necessary.
A world on fire
The world has been on fire for awhile now, but the conflagrations were mostly somewhere else, kept at bay via surrender of liquids, shoe removal and body scans at the airport. Or so we told ourselves.
The Hamas massacre of Oct. 7 has removed any false sense of security. It has revealed the violence lurking just below the surface in the U.S. and in many other “civilized” countries. Some Americans are openly siding with murderers, child killers and rapists.
Read More
This is the point where one might ask, “Weren’t these horrific killings committed in furtherance of a religion? Why would religion be the answer?”
John Lennon certainly thought it was not. His song, performed by Mrs. Carter’s friends Trisha Yearwood and Garth Brooks at the Tuesday memorial, says: “Imagine there's no countries. It isn't hard to do. Nothing to kill or die for, and no religion, too… Imagine all the people/ Livin’ life in peace…”
Judging from his lyrics, Mr. Lennon believed humans could live peaceably if they’d give up national identity, government, religion and private property, and just live for the moment. I believe almost the opposite to be true, based on observable human nature and, say, the last 115 years of human history. That includes the lives led by Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter.
In the parts of the world where ideas like Mr. Lennon’s have triumphed — the abolition of private property, religion and historical national identities — the millions murdered by these state-led ideologies dwarf those lost to other -isms. As the saying goes, “Ideas have consequences, and bad ideas have victims.”
Not all -isms are equal. Some belief systems are based on better observations and propose superior ideas. The consequences playing out in their adherents’ lives are usually reliable evidence.
Mrs. Carter’s teacher
Perhaps “Imagine” was deemed appropriate for Mrs. Carter’s memorial because she devoted her life to sharing her resources with others, meeting needs and seeking peace for all. But she did this precisely because she was following the teachings of Jesus, not those of Lennon or Lenin.
And she was free to do so because she lived in a country where the vast majority still embrace a “live and let live” creed and support a type of government that will (we hope) sustain and protect our way of life.
Contrary to Mr. Lennon’s lyrics, there are things worth dying for. Freedom of speech and religion, for example, and the right to life and liberty. Americans have long understood this to be our “secular religion,” something we share no matter where (or if) we worship.
Right now radical Islam and Putin-ism are the world’s two most active threats, but the former has a potentially greater reach. Radical Islam threatens the lives of Jews everywhere. To counter this new reality, peace-loving Muslims should repudiate the branches of Islam that pursue jihad, even at the risk of their own safety.
Jews must defy not only threats of violence, but also the possible despair that a just and loving God would allow atrocities like Oct. 7 to occur. Please indulge this Gentile as I urge you to, as a Chabad spokesman recently put it, “double down on being Jewish.” Go to synagogue. Help make a minyan. Pray.
A study released in February 2018 showed that although Pittsburgh’s Jewish population had grown since 2002, congregational affiliation had fallen precipitously.
The Tree of Life massacre was in October 2018. Last June, as the shooter’s death penalty was handed down, Rabbi Jeffrey Myers said, “In the face of the horror our community has experienced, I can think of no better response than practicing my Jewish faith and leading worship.”
Then came Oct. 7.
Defy a culture of death
To defy a suddenly flourishing culture of death, we need renewed strength. We need the consolation of like-minded friends. We need to seek what’s true and good and lasting.
If we return to church, temple or synagogue simply out of gratitude for the blessings these faith traditions have secured, and the desire to protect them, we may find this journey progresses to something greater, to something transcendent — something we didn’t realize was missing from our lives.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “I was wrong about random acts of kindness.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.