In Garfield, Charles King battles rummaging raccoons. In Deutschtown, I had to field flying poop.

Mr. King lives next to an “empty” building overflowing with masked mammals, but the abandoned house I’m contending with was ravaged by squatters.

Breakfast-spoiler alert: The house had lacked workable plumbing since its owner’s death, so unauthorized occupants got a medical toilet chair and, in a lovely bit of recycling, used plastic grocery bags to collect their waste, flinging it from an attic window onto all the adjacent properties.

Luckily for me, the city did not own this abandoned property, so I could actually get something done about it. The neighborhood groups now battling the City of Pittsburgh in court are not so fortunate.

Advertise with us

Using the state’s Abandoned and Blighted Property Conservatorship Act, as I did, these groups (including Mr. King’s in Bloomfield-Garfield) filed petitions to gain control of long-abandoned homes owned by the city but neglected to the point of posing imminent danger.

The communities seemed poised to win, but the city’s attorneys asked for a stay and have vowed to fight.

Read More

This is incomprehensible. It’s completely nuts.

The city’s lawyers obviously do not understand how conservatorship works, but worse than that, they don’t understand how their own process works — or is supposed to.

This is in important piece of the puzzle: Many of these blighted properties have come into the city’s ownership precisely because of the hard work done by the neighborhood groups they’re now fighting.

Advertise with us

I am not aware of a single property in my neighborhood that the city acquired on its own initiative. The huge majority of the 40 to 50 I’m very familiar with were initiated by our community council, and a handful by unhappy neighbors.

We scoured delinquent tax rolls for houses we knew were empty, and we filed the applications to put them in the treasurer’s sale.

We were told city staffers would research the properties, notify lien holders, put the parcels up for auction, clear the liens and titles if the properties remained unsold and release them to us, at cost, for revitalization — and that this whole process would take a couple of years.

What a joke. Paperwork for properties we pushed into the “T sale” eight and nine years ago is still languishing on someone’s desk while once-viable buildings disintegrate around us.

I don’t know how things worked before Luke Ravenstahl became mayor in 2006, because our community group formed in early 2008; but not long afterward, Urban Redevelopment Authority staffers reached out to us about proactively addressing blight.

Advertise with us

The URA even sent me to Baltimore with other community group leaders to learn the various ways its people tackled redevelopment. Like Pittsburgh, Baltimore has struggled with massive post-industrial population loss and property abandonment. One of the many valuable approaches we saw was pioneered by Johns Hopkins University and would have been a slam dunk here.

When the university needed to purchase entire blocks of abandoned houses to demolish for new research laboratories, it hired lots of paralegals to assist the city’s understaffed legal department. Through such cooperation, liens and titles were cleared apace, the few remaining homeowners were handsomely compensated, and labs were built.

Plenty of Pittsburgh communities want title to blighted properties not to demolish but to save them. The most cost-effective and eco-friendly houses are the ones that already exist. We have flush foundations that could replicate the Johns Hopkins intervention and finance some ambitious, community-friendly redevelopment projects.

Why would the city oppose groups willing and highly motivated to clean up its gigantic mess?

From Michael Korsh’s excellent reporting on the matter, we learn the city fears “it will be forced to come up with massive amounts of money to meet the challenges of upgrading the properties — or lose them.”

Advertise with us

This thinking is exactly backwards. Since an owner’s stake is protected and the owner basically gets veto power over any development plan, the city should step back and let the conservators — the community groups — find the “massive amounts of money” needed to revitalize these properties.

When the properties are eventually sold and conservatorship ended, the owner — the city — will receive 80% of the profit. Instead of fighting conservatorship, the city should enjoy its benefits.

Eighty percent is not a bad return for simply getting out of the people’s way.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com