If John Fetterman wins Pennsylvania’s open U.S. Senate seat, his victory will secure for Democrats the front-runner position in our nation’s ongoing threat-to-democracy sweepstakes.

And yes, that assessment takes into consideration the Walker-Warnock debacle in Georgia. There, at least, the dysfunction is clear, and the candidates’ extreme positions, while dismaying, are not subject to daily flip-flops.

Even Democratic Party stalwarts know that Mr. Fetterman lost Tuesday’s debate to Republican opponent Dr. Mehmet Oz in spectacularly sad fashion, and they are saying so, though mostly off the record.

As Reuters quoted “a senior Pennsylvania Democrat” the day after: ”I don’t know anyone, even the most staunch Fetterman supporters, who thinks that went well last night.”

Advertise with us

But plenty of power-brokers knew the truth about Mr. Fetterman’s post-stroke condition and nonetheless encouraged him onward. More shocking was the decision of his loved ones to enable this high-stakes campaign when he so obviously still needs to rest and recover.

Why did they let him press on? Did they hope the pace of his recovery would pick up in time for a breezy inauguration?

Did they arrogantly assume voters wouldn’t mind his frailty and just punch the Democratic ticket anyway?

Was it lust for power-by-association and for making it to the big-time Capitol gravy train?

Did cynical party leaders decide his health doesn’t matter so long as he votes as directed?

Advertise with us

Or did Mr. Fetterman himself recklessly insist on running and everyone fell in behind, for all the reasons above?

Whoever was responsible and whatever their motives, I believe this course of action disrespects the people of Pennsylvania. Some pundits have asserted that voters don’t care about a politician’s health or age or fitness; it’s “character” they want to see.

But such brash lying is itself a matter of character. Maintaining you are fit to serve in “the most distinguished deliberative body” on Earth when you can barely put a sentence together is pretty shocking.

A realist might argue that all politicians lie. I’d counter: Then at least let them lie in the time-honored tradition — about what they stand for and how they’ll vote. We heard some of that at the debate too, but this election should have been solely about ideas, not a doctor’s ridiculous note.

Mr. Fetterman’s candidacy may yet fail the basic principles of representative government in two additional ways.

Advertise with us

First, the lone debate was deliberately delayed until well past the beginning of mail-in voting. Pennsylvania’s Department of State currently reports 8.8 million registered voters. CNN reports almost 640,000 mail-in votes had already been cast as of October 25, while the U.S. Elections Project says it is 685,000.

Those numbers mean that somewhere between 7.2% and 7.8% of registered PA voters had chosen their new senator before the debate. Who are these early deciders?

According to CNN’s research and sources, 73% of Pennsylvania’s early voters have been Democrats and 88% are white. These figures reflect an increase in voters aged 65 and older, who have cast 60% of pre-election ballots so far (compared to 50% in 2020).

CNN noted that “these data aren’t predictive of ultimate outcomes,” since more Republicans vote on Election Day, but Reuters reported that worried Democrats “took hope in how many voters had cast ballots before the debate.”

In other words, they’re counting on low-information voters to provide the margin of victory. Whenever either party thinks like this, it’s ultimately bad for us all.

Advertise with us

The last way in which Mr. Fetterman’s candidacy may fail the Commonwealth is in the possibility of his incapacitation. Should he win but his health prevent completion of his term, the governor would appoint his successor. One man would decide, rather than the people; one man, without any restrictions on whom he may choose; one man who might not be from the same party.

From the lips of Fetterman foes and in prodigious comment sections online, what I hear and see is sympathy for John Fetterman tugging against bewilderment or indignation that such a critical contest should come down to this bizarre, regrettable, avoidable mess.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com