Three Mt. Lebanon moms have joined the ranks of parents across the nation suing schools and teachers over gender-identity instruction.

Made public 10 days ago, the Mt. Lebanon lawsuit is far from the first and very likely won’t be the last. But as important as it is to establish appropriate boundaries on such a controversial matter, the consequences of the lawsuits could be more far-reaching than school authorities seem to imagine.

We may someday look back on the 2020s as the time when disillusioned American taxpayers finally embraced the distinction between “public education” and “government-run schools” and abandoned the latter, opting for freedom of choice.

Much depends on what the nation’s educators choose to do next.

Advertise with us

Before encouraging first-graders to question their own still-developing gender identity, teachers and administrators should take some long moments to ponder what it is they hope to achieve.

Because we parents and grandparents are certainly asking ourselves, What exactly is it you activists want?

When you tell 6-year-olds that they might not be the little boy or girl they thought they were, what is your goal?

Make no mistake: This is activism on display. The aggressors in these conflicts are educators who presume to broach intensely private and ideologically combustible matters with their students, at very young ages, without informing parents.

From where most of us are standing, this unilateral action doesn’t seem reasonable, or even rational.

Advertise with us

From TikTok videos to roiling school districts, these let-me-enlighten-you talks usually include a version of this sentence: “Sometimes parents and doctors get it wrong.”

Actually, parents and doctors don’t get it wrong. The word “wrong” implies that we are discussing facts, not feelings, and one’s sex is a matter of scientific fact.

Gender is a term introduced very recently in human history, to encompass the ways human sexuality is expressed in one’s culture. Many social roles historically assigned to or adopted by the two sexes spring from their typical, inherent physiological differences.

Not everyone feels comfortable with those historical cultural roles, however; nor does every individual feel at ease in the body his or her DNA produced. I dare say that most humans feel intensely uncomfortable in their bodies for significant portions of life — almost certainly throughout puberty.

But these are feelings, not scientific fact. If no parent or doctor can tell a child how to feel about his or her body, how can a teacher?

Advertise with us

Since some teachers are presumptuously making this their business, without regard for parents’ rights and responsibilities, we have to ask, What is their goal?

In a Ludlow, Massachusetts, conflict, parents allege that a school counselor proactively identified students as non-binary, began addressing the students with gender-neutral pronouns and encouraged all students to use only those pronouns for all.

A district representative claimed that “teachers and staff have only ever had their students’ best interests in mind.” Who defines “best”?

It’s one thing for schools to adopt policies for responding kindly and professionally to children who present themselves as non-binary or transgender. It’s another thing entirely for those authorities to promote the concept and flout parental wisdom.

Try to imagine a teacher saying to her students, “I know you’re being raised as meat-eaters, but sometimes parents get things wrong.”

Advertise with us

Or, “I know your parents are raising you as a Christian/​Jew/​Muslim/​atheist, but sometimes parents get things wrong.”

These are highly personal matters. Though different, all constitute a line that educators should not cross.

If educators continue to do so, provoking appropriate legal action, the long-term result is likely to be increasing disenchantment with government-run schools. A report last June from the U.S. Department of Education showed that in the 2020-2021 school year, almost 2 million students — 3.8% — left the public school system. A “seismic change,” experts say — and they do not expect an easy recovery.

From the pandemic’s mask mandates and ineffective online learning, to racism-inciting exercises and gender dysphoria instruction, educators are giving parents and taxpayers much to distrust. The consequences could be long-lasting and profound.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com