Hindsight is not 20/20, not really, but time can make some things come clear. Enough time has passed since the COVID-19 pandemic began for us to ask ourselves, in corporate jargon, “What’s the takeaway?”

We need such an assessment because this health crisis isn’t over yet, and because other pandemics will doubtless arise in the years ahead.

Lively discussions in dentists’ offices, grocery stores and online meetings in recent days indicate that many, many people have absorbed stark lessons on the limitations of government. As a frustrated medical professional remarked to me Thursday, “The voters will have the final word.”

From congressional stand-offs to the state-store debacle to Pittsburgh’s parking follies, governments at every level have failed in essential functions and rational decision-making — even those that loudly, constantly claim to be “data-driven.” By contrast, we as a society cannot and should not stop celebrating the overwhelming decency that so many citizens have displayed in countless, truly creative ways.

Advertise with us

The human spirit is adaptive and resilient — qualities best expressed by individuals, families and other small, cohesive units. But individuals and small social units can fracture, especially when ill-advised government policies amplify Mother Nature’s ugly side. Some official policies have done so.

I skipped the county level in my list because Pennsylvania’s counties have by and large not acted autonomously. One exception is Beaver County, whose leaders rightly defied destructive Harrisburg diktats. The people living in and leading Beaver County have better insight on what is best for Beaver, because — like individuals and private groups — the closer a government is to a problem, the more appropriately it can respond.

The federal government’s list of shortcomings is extensive, including no stockpiles or domestic manufacturing of essential equipment; inadequate guidance for intra-state coordination; and confusing, contradictory news briefings from Washington, D.C.

This last failing — confusion and about-faces in official pronouncements — is the easiest to forgive because responses at every level must change as new information about COVID-19 emerges or proves unreliable.

But there’s no excuse from now on for policies that favor foreign production over American industry, or that favor short-term gain at the cost of long-term, long-lasting loss. And there’s no excuse for harsh measures weeks after science makes clear that a carefully targeted and limited quarantine would suffice.

Advertise with us

Here in Pennsylvania, Gov. Tom Wolf and Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine have insisted their approach would be data-driven. But which data? It could also have been fact-driven. Had it been, our lockdown would have looked a lot different and started easing up weeks ago.

From day one, shutting down game lands, golf courses and other outdoor recreational sites was just plain stupid. These places and activities have social distancing built in, promote mental health and get people outdoors, which is safer than indoors. Closed anyway, they should have been reopened a month ago.

We’ve also known for weeks that the elderly and the already-ill are the most vulnerable population, that coronavirus thrives in close quarters, that city dwellers are at greater risk than those in rural areas.

Why not funnel scarce resources to protect the vulnerable and to quarantine (and adequately pay) the workers who come and go each day, absurdly, to serve them? Instead, a few leaders shut down the entire state, pushing millions of people into unemployment, destroying family finances, disrupting education and routine health care, creating food insecurity and stressing family dynamics.

Gov. Wolf, now in his second term, will not be in office to face the long-term devastation caused by his heavy-handed, unimaginative policies.

Advertise with us

As for the state’s ludicrous Liquor Control Board system, a progressive friend said, “If this crisis doesn’t end the LCB, then nothing will.”

If we get the government we deserve, this crisis should send us to the ballot box, mindful of what government can and cannot do, and painfully aware that local elected public servants are more responsive and accountable than strangers in far away places.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com