Only two moments can offset, for me, the cringe I felt throughout all of Stephanie Borowicz’s prayer last Monday afternoon in the state House of Representatives.

If you can bear to watch the video online, the first moment of relief comes at the beginning — when Speaker Mike Turzai’s eyes slightly widen and his mouth opens and you can almost see a “Holy Crap-oli” thought bubble above his head.

The second moment is when he touches Rep. Borowicz’s elbow to hasten the end of her feverish and wildly inappropriate outpouring.

I say this as a professing follower of Jesus: I can’t remember ever having heard a more destructive prayer.

Advertise with us

On a lighter note, I’m reminded of British aristocrats at Prince Harry and Meghan Markle’s wedding last year, slack-jawed and bug-eyed at the sermon of the Most Rev. Michael Curry, African-American head of the Episcopal Church. Their expressions were cartoonish compared to the restraint visible last Monday in Harrisburg.

As unaccustomed to religious fervor as the English upper crust may be, at least Rev. Curry’s sermon was delivered in a church, where it belonged. And it was joyous and winsome, not full of veiled warnings and sectarian boundary-marking.

In her Monday prayer, Mrs. Borowicz, a Clinton County Republican, mentioned “Jesus” a dozen times; invoked his divinity and the “Second Coming”; cited Washington at Valley Forge, Lincoln at Gettysburg and the “Founding Fathers” at Independence Hall; thanked God for various Pennsylvania leaders and for President Donald Trump’s support of Israel; and asked Jesus’ forgiveness for all of us having forgotten him.

I would have found this prayer over the top even in a church. But since it was uttered in the Statehouse, a shared secular space, Mrs. Borowicz had just handed fresh fuel to those who seek to banish religious speech from the public realm.

She name-checked Jesus like other people say “um.” It would’ve been weird on any day, but just prior to the swearing-in of Movita Johnson-Harrell, the House’s first Muslim woman, it offended many.

Advertise with us

Mr. Turzai did quick damage control by inviting one of Ms. Johnson-Harrell’s guests to offer a Muslim prayer. He also reminded everyone that any prayer offered in the House should accommodate people of all faiths.

The House’s prayer tradition is currently under challenge from a group of atheists, humanists and free-thinkers who oppose House guidelines limiting prayer to those who believe in God or a higher power.

They won their lawsuit last fall, but the House has appealed to the Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. House leaders assert their practice does not violate the Constitution’s Establishment Clause since it favors no particular religion.

While I agree with the House position as a matter of philosophy and law, wouldn’t it make for better policy — and politics — to expand this opportunity to all?

At some point, yes, an idea can be expanded so far that words lose their meaning: Prayer without God is not prayer, it’s an inspiring “thought for the day” — but that’s not nothing, is it? And the competing ideas put forward in “prayer” can and should do battle in any alert listener’s mind.

Advertise with us

I don’t doubt Mrs. Borowicz’s sincerity, but her prayer failed in both the secular and religious realms. Its political toxicity was evident.

On the other hand, while Ms. Johnson-Harrell was temperate in most interviews, she went too far in describing the prayer as “Islamophobic, xenophobic and absolutely degrading.” Whether Mrs. Borowicz is “-phobic” of opposing views, only her God knows, and her sectarianism equally excludes all other belief systems, whether Muslim, Hindu, Jewish, atheist, you name it.

But if it degraded anyone or anything, it was Jesus and his Gospel. That, for me, is tragic.

When Jesus spoke with nonbelievers, he was unfailingly inviting and gentle. He reserved his divisive messages for the super-religious — something we modern believers too easily forget. Who really should be praying for forgiveness?

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (ruthanndailey@hotmail.com).