If you use Google to search for the word “tribalism,” an interesting dictionary box pops up. The first line in the noun’s definition reads, “the state or fact of being organized in a tribe or tribes,” but the bullet point just beneath it notes, “derogatory.”
The italics are Google’s. The adjective must be the elite’s.
“Tribalism” has emerged in recent years as a handy political put-down, a predictable response to President Donald Trump’s often outrageous rhetoric, but accusing others of tribalism is — by definition — hypocritical and, at best, truly unhelpful.
As put-downs go, you’d expect better from people who fancy themselves smarter than their targets. In fact, I’d argue that tribalism has been getting a bum rap.
The latest example comes from former President Barack Obama, courtesy of an aide’s just-published memoir, as he struggled to understand Mr. Trump’s victory.
“What if we were wrong?” President Obama reportedly mused to staffers with him in the presidential limousine. “Maybe we pushed too far … Maybe people just want to fall back into their tribe.”
Well, that’s what Mr. Obama did upon leaving office, didn’t he? After chilling for a while with British billionaire Richard Branson on his private island, the Obamas spent more than a year hanging out with celebrities like Tom Hanks and Oprah Winfrey, working on their presidential library in Chicago (controversial for its community-disrespecting approach) and writing their memoirs for a reported $60 million. Their tribe is the super-rich. That’s where they feel comfortable in a sometimes inhospitable world.
Accusing human beings of tribalism is very close to, if not outright, tautology. Organizing ourselves into groups is what humans do, because it’s what nature does in and to us. At some point in history, for instance, my ancestors looked at each other and said, “We have very light skin and can’t survive this heat. Let’s all move north and start Ireland.”
We are programmed to survive. Organizing people, information and priorities is an essential and primal skill — especially in an ever more complex world.
Various sociological studies have tried to measure how many and what kind of relationships the typical human being can manage. Using studies of primates’ brains and behavior, British anthropologist Robin Dunbar proposed that the average person can comfortably maintain about 150 relationships.
Complementing the so-called “Dunbar’s number” are two figures from a January 2011 study in the American Journal of Sociology, in which a research team led by Tian Zheng of Columbia University found that the average American knows 600 people but knows only 10 to 25 “well enough to say they trust them.”
Blood is thicker than water, the old saying goes, and we do usually prioritize our immediate family first. Beyond our kin, interests and ideas divide and unite us; we cluster with non-relatives in churches and synagogues, political parties, unions, private clubs, PTAs, 12-step groups, bowling leagues, book clubs, knitting circles and so on.
The person decrying someone else’s tribalism is himself a member of a tribe — hence his hypocrisy — and simply may be seeking a tactical advantage by making the other guy feel ashamed of his group or seem distasteful to the others whose support the accuser needs.
It might be effective short-term politics, but it is terrible leadership. And there’s not much distance between “bitter clingers,” “deplorables,” “Mexican rapists” and “s**thole countries.” All emerge from lips twisted in a sneer.
For this large nation to flourish, we must cooperate with those who do not share a tribal connection, whether blood or water or secret handshake. We will not be inspired to do this by our mocking politicians or pundits — or forced into it, a la Stalin, Mao, et al., and their modern state-loving heirs.
And why would we abandon our tribes? After all, in smaller groups we have the most influence and make the most difference for the good. The smaller the group, the more direct the accountability, and the more likely that loving relationships will temper our less attractive impulses. This is where civilized society begins, or is supposed to.
As Edmund Burke more eloquently put it: “To love the little platoon we belong to in society, is the first principle (the germ as it were) of public affections. It is the first link in the series by which we proceed towards a love to our country, and to mankind.”
We understand the parent who sacrifices herself to save her child. We marvel at the individual who takes a bullet for a stranger. The first leads to the second.
So we must embrace our tribes. We just can’t embrace only our tribes — not if our great American experiment is to survive.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.