The only constant is change, they say, and when I first heard this adage, well into adulthood, it provided a comfort of sorts. A bittersweet comfort.

I imagine most people take it that way, at least those of us who hear it or say it with a resigned shrug. But there are those who sometimes say it — politicians, investors, bureaucrats — as an excuse for the unwelcome changes they are forcing into other people’s lives.

Change is not an undifferentiated force. Not all change is inevitable, and not all of it is good, but it often takes years before hindsight lets us sort through the outcomes.

A dozen of us from all over the city could see many decades of change inscribed on the very buildings of Pittsburgh’s Spring Garden Valley as we took a walking tour through it Saturday.

Advertise with us

Our guide was John Canning, retired school teacher and longtime stalwart of Allegheny City Society, whose members seek to keep alive the history of the place we now call “the North Side.”

From the many sets of city steps, to the leaded glass around a home’s front door, to the stone-edged arches in the northern face of Troy Hill, Mr. Canning used the past’s visible remnants to paint a picture of how people used to live and work.

Those stone niches were new to me. I’d noticed them before but imagined the wrong use — something to do with fresh springs. Instead they were part of the cellars of long-ago-demolished houses, carved out for cold storage in the mid-to-late 1800s, well before the time of modern refrigeration.

And as we strolled past on a very hot September Saturday, we could feel cool air pouring out from passageways between the hillside homes that remain.

Those same pre-refrigeration days saw great growth in the local meat processing industry. Since slaughtered meat from the Great Plains couldn’t have been kept cold all the way to the East Coast, live animals were shipped across country and stopped here at the Herrs Island cattleyards and slaughterhouses.

Advertise with us

Mr. Canning said his boyhood friends who attended North Catholic High School atop Troy Hill “would pray the wind would blow the smells up from the Heinz plant instead of from Herrs Island.”

But the busy slaughterhouses supplied at least a half-dozen tanneries in Spring Garden Valley. Mr. Canning has an old print ad for “insulation paper” made with the hair from animal hides. My own home in adjacent Deutschtown was built, we’re told, as a leather dye factory. And one of the stops on our Saturday tour was the former Old Honesty Soap factory, also based on the bygone meat industry, now a mini-storage facility.

Why are those businesses gone? Man-made refrigeration and faster transportation made it unnecessary to ship live cattle halfway across the country.

Those technological changes were for the greater good, and the local decline they contributed to was fairly gradual. A far more sudden jolt to this neighborhood’s economy was Prohibition, an ill-conceived and very destructive change in American law — meant for social good, of course.

Brewing has been a major Pittsburgh industry since the British built Fort Pitt, but breweries were especially plentiful in the Deutschtown and Spring Garden neighborhoods, heavily populated by German-speaking peoples.

Advertise with us

Today most of those breweries are nothing but a memory. But if Prohibition destroyed local economies and turned average people into scofflaws, nothing did more economic damage to the “flats” of the North Side than the construction of Interstate 279 in the late 1980s and the flight to the suburbs.

I don’t need to go into any detail about that. It is history recent enough that most adults understand the economic and political forces that were at work and the consequences of those decisions.

As today’s power-brokers contemplate remaking entire industries (health insurance, energy), it would be nice if they spent more time pondering the unforeseen consequences of their always-stellar intentions.

My oldest neighbors — the survivors — remember when breweries and tanneries still stood, along with the houses of people those businesses employed. The powerless always get hit hardest by inevitable change. They get tired of also bearing the brunt of ill-conceived changes and arrogant actions from on high, the downside of which could have been anticipated.

One highlight of Saturday’s tour was a sneak peek at the soon-to-open Threadbare Cider House on Spring Garden Avenue, from the folks whose Wigle Whiskey Barrelhouse has galvanized redevelopment. In a wry juxtaposition, this new facility occupies an old tannery and stands next to another long-empty tannery.

Advertise with us

Alcohol is making a making a big comeback in the Valley. Wry or rye, it softens the blows of change.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com