On March 20, I quit a decades-long habit. A distasteful overdose of the drug itself cured me. (Or so I thought.)
For two decades I have watched two broadcast news shows, as well as a sampling of cable news coverage, pretty much every night of the week.
But no more. On March 20, “NBC Nightly News” was so politically skewed, so larded with exaggerated claims and emotionally charged vocabulary that I had to laugh in disbelief, and talk back. I never even made it to my usual dose of CBS.
Lester Holt began breathlessly: “President Trump’s own FBI director shoots down the president’s claim about being wire-tapped.”
Mr. Comey was appointed by Barack Obama.
Testifying before Congress, Mr. Comey “dropped two bombshells” that “land[ed] at the White House doorstep” as he “joined the growing chorus of intelligence officials and lawmakers rejecting President Trump’s tweeted claims of being wiretapped by President Obama.”
The video clip of Director Comey? “I have no information that supports those tweets, and we have looked carefully inside the FBI.”
Bombshell? No, that was pretty circumspect. And over the past week Congress has been learning there’s much more to the story than this, involving Obama officials, so why not tell the whole story?
The other bombshell was that the Trump campaign had been “under FBI investigation since last summer in connection with Russian meddling in the election.”
That’s considerably stronger than Mr. Comey’s careful “[we’re] investigating the Russian government’s efforts to interfere in the 2016 election … the nature of any links … and whether there was any coordination between the campaign and Russia’s efforts.”
In response, Mr. Holt said, “the White House is clinging to the discredited wiretap claim as it tries to change the narrative.”
Yes, away from NBC’s lopsided narrative. Nice.
As Andrea Mitchell’s report began, the Trump tweet appeared: “Just found out that Obama had my ‘wires tapped’ in Trump Tower just before the victory.”
Those are quote-quotes or air-quotes in that tweet. Why not ask him why he used them?
Ms. Mitchell then mentioned “possible coordination between the president’s campaign and Russia’s hacking of Democrats — a lengthy probe that could lead all the way to the White House.”
It’s already known that the probe will be lengthy? And which administration will it actually lead to? Could we skip conjecture and stick to facts?
She gave lots of time to Rep. Denny Heck, D-Wash., who asserted the hacking was “in part an inside job” — Americans helping Russians “attack our country and our democracy.”
Well heck, Denny, the Russians only hacked the Clinton campaign staff’s very embarrassing emails. And calling it an “inside job” isn’t just “laying out the facts,” as you claim; it’s reaching an inflammatory conclusion. Kind of like Donald Trump’s tweet …
Ms. Mitchell referred to “Comey’s rebukes” of Mr. Trump. Reporter Peter Alexander later used the same word.
Rebukes? That’s not an accurate summary of Mr. Comey’s judicious testimony. That’s NBC spin.
Next up, reporter Halley Jackson named various Trump campaign figures, including “Roger Stone — a notorious GOP operative — [who] demanded his chance to respond to what he calls ‘smears’ at [that day’s] hearing.”
“Notorious”? If that’s not a smear itself, it’s a startling assessment. Just for fun, readers, look up “notorious GOP operative” online, then “notorious Democratic operative.” Compare numbers of hits and nature of websites.
Mr. Holt opined, “After a string of unproven claims, will this president struggle to keep the trust of the American public?”
Pot? Kettle?
While it’s too early for comparisons to Watergate, Mr. Brokaw replied, this story “is not going to go away any time soon.”
He was wrong: The story vanished — just as soon as soon as it became clear, online archives show, that Obama administration official Susan Rice had repeatedly requested to know the names of Americans caught up in our surveillance of the Russians — names that someone then leaked (a felony).
But I decided to give network news another go last Monday. It was more of the same. As the 100-day mark loomed, NBC said, “when it comes to legislative achievements, … the president’s record is thin.”
The president is not a legislator. His supporters want the federal government to do less, to roll back left-wing excess. You’re asserting a false standard — why?
In Ms. Mitchell’s report on how Mr. Obama is high-mindedly ignoring his successors “slams,” she included audio of President Trump saying, “I inherited a mess.”
Funny, that’s exactly what Mr. Obama said in his first term… I’m pretty certain NBC didn’t call it a “slam.”
My addiction is broken, but it wasn’t new technology that did the trick. It was the stubborn failure of the old technology’s nattering nabobs.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.