When President George W. Bush addressed a joint session of Congress on Sept. 20, 2001, he said Americans were asking themselves why radical Islamic terrorists hate us so much that they’d kill thousands of innocent civilians.
His answer was, “They hate our freedoms: our freedom of religion, our freedom of speech, our freedom to vote and assemble and disagree with each other.”
He was right, and those words are still true, or mostly. How free are we, really, to disagree with each other?
You would think our sorrowful experiences with religious terrorism would reinvigorate our commitment to safeguarding one another’s liberties, but that is not necessarily so. Conflicts over these liberties continue, and each demonstrates again the foresight of our founders.
In a letter to Thomas Jefferson in June 1813, John Adams extolled the virtues of social checks and balances and of what we now call “diversity.” He claimed any sect, if unchecked, would persecute the others.
“The Deists would persecute Christians, and Atheists would persecute Deists, with as unrelenting Cruelty, as any Christians would persecute them or one another. Know thyself, human nature!”
But we don’t know ourselves. Here and abroad, people of varied persuasions are finding it difficult to tolerate any display of the consciences of others.
During its annual August vacation season, France took this problem to a new level that managed to be both comical and appalling. Nearly 30 French municipalities passed laws forbidding “burkinis,” the modest swimsuits that observant Muslim women were wearing on local beaches.
This swimming apparel, which exposes only the face, hands and feet, was perceived as so overtly religious in nature that it upset people in bikinis, thongs and Speedos and threatened public order.
But no action takes place in a vacuum. The Nice ban specifically mentioned the massacre of July 14 — in which a Muslim truck driver ran down hundreds of revelers on Bastille Day, killing 85. And on Aug. 23, near the massacre site, police confronted a modestly clothed woman napping on the beach and actually forced her to remove some clothing. They said her outfit did not “respect good morals and secularism.”
The episode sparked an uproar. The Interior Minister called the burkini bans unconstitutional. France’s highest administrative court ruled against one resort town’s ban, warning other towns the ruling set a precedent. Many mayors announced their defiance and the issue will probably end up in the European Court of Human Rights.
All this over appropriate swimwear.
Britain’s counterpart to this was a years-long legal drama over crucifixes. A British Airways flight attendant was suspended and a nurse demoted for wearing necklaces with crosses. They appealed to the European Court of Human Rights in 2012 after being denied satisfactory justice in British courts.
When it was revealed that their own government would argue against them, many Britons were shocked. And it made headlines when a Russian conglomerate announced it would no longer buy British goods for its factories or allow British-made vehicles on its premises or use British Airways due to "the persecution of Christians in Great Britain.”
That’s a fine example of the social checks and balances John Adams hoped for, but the need for such pushback is regrettable. In both the French burkini and the British crucifix cases, it is an intentionally secular state — rather than a religious one — that is suppressing freedom.
It’s hard to imagine either brouhaha unfolding in America, where Amish citizens, dark-suited or long-skirted Mormons and people with religious jewelry of all kinds flourish and even have their own reality television shows.
America’s recent conflicts over freedom of religion are about actions rather clothing. They address, for instance, whether devout Catholics and Evangelicals have an obligation to provide birth control to employees or to participate in same-sex wedding ceremonies.
The similarity between Europe and America, though, is that aggressive secularists claim that by manifesting a different sensibility than that of the majority — or of the ruling secular elite — the religious have committed acts of aggression or hate.
True tolerance does not mean agreement or approval. It does not rule out distaste and discomfort. It simply signals a willingness to coexist in liberty so long as no harm is done.
Yes, the tyrannical hate freedom. Sometimes their attacks on it are acts of war, but sometimes they wage war through the law.
The price of liberty is eternal vigilance — on matters great and small. The seemingly small matters may have greater consequence than we can foresee.
That British flight attendant won her appeal for back pay, by the way, while the nurse lost her discrimination case. So who can predict the fate of the outrageously modest burkini?
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.