The conversation always follows the same skittish path, no matter who initiates it.
It may start innocuously enough, but if the topic turns to politics, I summon my go-to noncommittal phrase: “What a crazy year!”
If the response is “I’ll say” or “You’re telling me,” my next step depends on the speaker’s tone. If it is exuberant, I won’t go much further with someone who apparently likes the craziness. (Life is short; why waste any of it?)
If the tone is rueful, though, then I know we are kindred spirits, brought together by the current, tragic insanity of American politics.
And soon enough, we are confessing to each other that this may well be a national election we skip.
If so, it will be the first in my life. I may have forgotten to vote in an off-year election once when my now-adult children were babies and we were moving to a different city every 18 months, but I’m certain I’ve never missed pulling the lever for the president of my choice.
A 50-something friend just a couple of days ago tiptoed his way into this now-familiar conversation with me. He admitted that in this new millennium, he feels he has voted each time “for the lesser of two evils.”
At my objection, he said he didn’t mean the word “evil” literally — until now. In prior election cycles, we’ve had some fine, if flawed, candidates. But this year, we agree that literal evil is at hand.
While Bernie Sanders was still in the race, I could honestly say there was at least one admirable candidate among the three left standing. While his ideas are unworkable and/or incoherent, he seems sincere, principled and not an egomaniac.
So, of course, he’s history. And we have gone from three Democrats to two. Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump.
Yes, Democrats. Mr. Trump has little in common with classical Republicanism. He is neither a conservative nor a libertarian. He is an opportunist.
He has historically supported big-government policies (which tend to favor the rich and powerful, like him) and has donated more to Democrats — until four years ago, when he ramped up his GOP gifts, perhaps with his eyes already on the 2016 prize.
Democrat foot soldiers like to pretend Mr. Trump’s racism and nativism are the embodiment of a GOP caricature they’ve been peddling for years. But they’d be hard-pressed to find any comments from pre-Trump public figures as racist and condescending as those from their own. (Think Joe Biden and Harry Reid on Barack Obama, circa 2008.)
That doesn’t excuse Mr. Trump’s repulsiveness. He does, in fact, capture America’s political id. He expresses an immature electorate’s fears and dislikes that were previously deemed too loathsome to say out loud. His utterances provide the same kind of thrill that some people get from slasher flicks.
But his canniest opportunism of all was seeing the crowded GOP primary field not as daunting, but as ripe for conquest.
Way back in 2015, Republicans looked at their huge array of candidates as an embarrassment of riches. But the sheer numbers meant that none was a slam dunk in the way Hillary Clinton was long known to be.
So a candidate with no discernible philosophy but possessed of a massive ego, great name recognition and the drive to win the ultimate contest would not hesitate to co-opt the GOP. In retrospect, it is a “duh” moment.
What still stuns me and my “lesser of two evils” friends is that primary voters embraced this nutty impostor.
You could say somewhat the same about Bernie Sanders. His ideas are an extreme version of classical leftism, where Mr. Trump’s are usually antithetical to classical Republicanism — but both men tapped into their party faithful’s deep discontent.
Both men understand that the people on the bottom half of America’s ladder feel betrayed and stepped on by Washington’s permanent upper class.
That betrayal is real — but the answer was not, is not and never will be to torch the republic.
Mr. Sanders would have trashed it for the sake of socialism’s faux equality, but even his party’s adults could see there’s no way to pay for it.
Mr. Trump’s ever-changing inanities make a mockery of self-government. So do the rule-breaking, incompetence and arrogance of Ms. Clinton, who has always been for sale. She would have no place on the national stage if she were a man.
This is a tragic moment. Why would any citizen vote in favor of a demolition derby?
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.