Donald Trump is a tornado roaring through the republic, leaving behind chaos, despair and the far-flung debris of once-solid structures like the GOP.

Perhaps the upside to his candidacy will appear each time we dig through some Trumpian debris and sort out what’s salvageable. This time, though, what if we built something better, post-storm?

In yet-another foot-in-mouth episode, Mr. Trump has achieved the nearly impossible: He has revealed common ground for pro-life and pro-choice advocates.

On a CNN show, MSNBC’s Chris Matthews pressed the formerly pro-choice Mr. Trump at length for more details on his new pro-life position.

Advertise with us

“This isn’t something you can dodge,” Mr. Matthews said. “If you say that abortion is a crime or … murder, you have to deal with it under the law. Should abortion be punished?”

“People in certain parts of the Republican Party and conservative Republicans would say yes,” Mr. Trump claimed.

“For the women?”

“Yes.”

Both sides assailed him — pro-lifers in dismay, as he destructively misrepresented their decades-old, widely held views; pro-choicers with relish, as his answer bolsters the Democrats’ “war on women” theme.

Advertise with us

Perhaps that was the very purpose of the question; Chris Matthews is nothing if not a dyed-in-the-wool Democrat, and pro-choice hardliners took his gift and ran with it.

“Trump Accidentally Tells the Truth About GOP’s Position on Abortion,” proclaimed Rachel Maddow. “Trump’s Abortion Gaffe Highlights GOP’s Intellectual Dishonesty” asserted the headline on Ruth Marcus’ Washington Post column.

But “intellectual dishonesty,” as Ms. Marcus dubs it, exists on all sides of this issue and was, in fact, built right into Mr. Matthews’s question: “This isn’t something you can dodge” — really?

Of course you can. Pro-choice leaders like scholar Camille Paglia and former Planned Parenthood president Faye Wattleton (among others) call abortion “murder” or “killing” (respectively), but neither clamors for anyone to face punishment for it.

At least they acknowledge a fact ignored by the slogans, like Ms. Marcus’, touting women’s “freedom to choose what to do with their own bodies”: Sadly, there is a second body involved in this decision, a distinct human body with its own unique DNA, a human life that is going to end.

Advertise with us

Don’t hold your breath waiting for Mr. Matthews & Co. to press abortion supporters on this “intellectual dishonest[y].”

Also dishonest was the hypothetical nature of his question: There is no chance that a GOP-controlled Congress will pass a bill outlawing abortion — they couldn’t even pass a bill stripping Planned Parenthood of its taxpayer funding — and there’s no chance that any legislative ban anywhere would survive a challenge in the courts.

What’s “dishonest” on the non-Trump pro-life side? The last five GOP nominees have supported anti-abortion legislation with exceptions for rape and incest, and as Ms. Marcus correctly asks, “why should it matter … how the pregnancy came into being?” Moreover, their positions are not explicitly supported by the party platform.

Enough. At some point, “intellectual dishonesty” is not the correct term. Let’s call it “intellectual inconsistency” and — in order to be honest — let’s acknowledge inconsistencies exist in almost every viewpoint it is possible to have on abortion.

Why the inconsistencies? Because the vast majority of us are torn between tragically conflicting interests. Our hearts break for a woman who does not want to bear the child she’s carrying, while we anguish over the innocent human life ended by an abortion.

Advertise with us

The only consistent positions are at either extreme; one is barbaric and the other mercilessly idealistic. Living in this world and maintaining our divided society’s civil “marriage” demands that we struggle to accommodate, as far as humanely possible, our irreconcilable differences.

As a culture, we have actually been managing to do this. We have let stand the “right to choose” inaugurated so rashly by Roe v. Wade, but we overwhelming recoil from the inhumane extremes it allowed. We are moving steadily toward protections for the unborn — particularly as science reveals the human-ness of the fetus and enables survival of ever-younger preemies.

After a huge late-1990s jump in the ranks of “pro-life” citizens, we have remained pretty evenly divided between the two positions for years, even as the number of abortions continues a steady decline.

All this has been achieved without any ban, without the heavy or unreasonable weight of the law.

Rueful compassion for one another is not “dishonest.” Whipping up destructive controversy to advance a partisan agenda is.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com