Here I was, marveling at how President Barack Obama has truly been running circles around Senate Republicans in the Supreme Court nomination process — not just running, but leaping and pirouetting, while they flail.
And then it emerges he’s seeking a huge post-White House raise for himself and our other multi-millionaire ex-presidents — an 18 percent boost in the budget created by the Former Presidents Act. Just like that, his political instincts are thrown into doubt.
If there’s any single shared emotion driving the protest voters of both political parties this year, it is economic resentment. Why stoke that resentment, unless the president’s goal — besides a life of even greater ease than taxpayers already provide — is to galvanize more support for Bernie Sanders and virtually any Republican?
But I come to praise the president, not to harry him, and he has indeed outwitted Senate leaders with the selection of Judge Merrick Garland.
The Republicans fired first, damaging only themselves. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell declared mere hours after Justice Antonin Scalia’s death that a new justice should not be named until a new president is elected; within days, his colleagues were firmly on board.
This might be red meat for party faithful, but they are already in full battle mode. Given the current political circus, what the GOP needed was a moment to pre-emptively and very publicly claim the political high ground.
Yes, the president is a lame duck and not a very popular one. (His approval rating has just reached 50 percent for the first time in years. Perhaps this election season’s slate of candidates casts him in a suddenly positive light.)
And yes, when still a senator, he himself advocated filibustering Samuel Alito’s nomination to the Supreme Court, asserting that a judge’s “philosophy [and] ideology” were fair grounds for opposition.
And yes, though Mr. Obama has proven more popular than his opponent in two national elections, his own left-wing ideology has been resoundingly repudiated by voters — at every other level of government, particularly in 2014.
But none of this matters in the public relations arena.
The Republicans have had 35 years — since Ronald Reagan’s first term — to comprehend that they will never get a fair shake in mass media news coverage. The best they can hope for is occasional, begrudging neutrality.
Instead of boxing themselves in from the get-go, Republicans could have soberly announced they intended to do their constitutional duty — to advise and consent, period. Hard to cast that in a negative light.
Of course, the Constitution leaves the details of that obligation up to the Senate, which sets its own rules, priorities and calendar. The GOP leadership could then have proceeded with an eye on a wildly unpredictable presidential race and the possibility they might end up with a much worse nominee, post-November.
They could have reasonably delayed hearings until the current Supreme Court term ends — in late June — and could have used summer recess and campaign schedules to set a deliberate pace.
After all, both parties, when in power, have successfully blocked nominees from a president of the opposing party for many months on end. “Committee doesn’t meet again today” is a “dog bites man” story. In our drama-craved times, it isn’t going to top the news cycle.
But the GOP having announced an openly obstructionist position upfront (instead of making nice but pursuing a low-key, obstructionist-as-needed agenda), President Obama made them look foolish with a careful choice.
Judge Garland is a former prosecutor in the first President Bush’s Justice Department and a respected judge with 19 years on the U.S. Court of Appeals.
While NBC termed him a “moderate … maybe a little bit to the left” and CBS a “moderate liberal.” Fox News commentator Judge Andrew Napolitano described him as “the most conservative nominee to the Supreme Court by a Democratic president in the modern era.”
He further characterized the nomination as a “lose-lose,” saying the president was “more interested in the politics … than in his own philosophical legacy.”
But the president had little choice: A firmly left-wing nominee wouldn’t have had the proverbial snowball’s chance. Forced to forgo an ideological approach, he pursued the political one and nailed it.
Barack Obama may be a lame duck, but he’s still a faithful party soldier. With this nomination, he did as much for his side in the battle of ideas as he possibly could.
And then he asked all of us for a raise! This is some crazy year.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.