The remaining presidential candidates in both parties, though less diverse than at the outset, nevertheless still include: inveterate liars, inarticulate gasbags, humorless scolds, self-serving opportunists and pie-in-the-sky fantasists.
(I’ve been studying the attack style of one of the candidates. Guess who?)
(Though in fairness to myself, my vocabulary is considerably better than his. To borrow his phrase, it’s huge!)
Most of the candidates deserve at least two of the epithets above, and one candidate sweeps them all. (Again, guess who?)
Some very admirable people have quit the race, and the two remaining candidates who, in my estimation, deserve our respect are polling the worst. It is, all told, a very sad time for the republic.
Since rational policies and good character don’t count for much in this demoralizing presidential season, I might as well put forward my own shallow and arbitrary test for the highest office in the land:
Who can I stand to listen to for the next four years?
Being able to listen to any president for a prolonged amount of time would represent progress for me.
I’m going to be blunt here, because it appears that many of my fellow citizens now value bluntness above all other qualities: I have not listened to more than a few minutes of any president’s speech for a very, very long time.
News organizations should not be disheartened by this approach or the possibility of its catching on. After all, the time I’ve saved by skipping the painful broadcasts of all these speeches, I have spent on their websites reading the transcripts and their pundits’ varied analyses. Win-win!
I heartily recommend this method to everybody — no matter whether it’s the candidate’s uninspiring delivery or logic-challenged content that turns you off.
I started limiting my speech exposure during the era of Bush the Elder, but each president has provided me with plenty of justification for my time-saving, cringe-reducing method — even Barack Obama, the allegedly stellar orator.
It’s been approximately seven years since anyone asserted that about him, because the unspoken truth is that Candidate Obama rarely waxed eloquent on any subject except himself. The presidency demands other topics.
And since political incorrectness is big this year — no, it’s huge! — let me say that Mr. Obama has an odd sense of rhetorical rhythm. Since roughly January 2009, there have been very few lyrical, soaring sentences; only burst-of-gunfire phrases separated by long pauses.
When the pitch goes down in each word-burst, he is lecturing us; when it goes up, he’s peeved about how uncooperative we are.
Donald Trump also speaks in short bursts, but these are complete “thoughts” and tumble forth willy-nilly. Like Mr. Obama, he frequently uses a downward pitch pattern, but — ever explicit — Mr. Trump marries it to words like “total loser” and “worthless,” just in case you miss his drift.
He does offset the downs with some ups — “Make America great again!,” “It’s gonna be huuuge!” — but these slogans remain detail-free. It is word salad. Listening to him makes me want to hurt myself with a sharp object.
Bernie Sanders? His voice and accent are not exactly euphonious, but I like his sound anyway because it’s distinctively American and far from bland.
He is a man of good character — honest, hardworking and optimistic — but the challenge in listening to him is that, while he’s identified some important national problems, his analysis of what’s ailing us is seriously incomplete, and his solutions for these incompletely identified woes are largely fantasy. I try to limit my fantasy intake to the occasional Disney film.
Hilary Clinton? She’s not shrill; it’s just that someone needs to explain to her how a microphone works. And how the human voice works. Yelling ≠ authenticity.
As a veteran church-pew occupier, I hear in Ted Cruz, the son of a Baptist preacher, the practiced, faux intimacies of a skilled audience manipulator. His voice suggests empathic engagement that doesn’t often reach his eyes.
The kind interpretation of this disconnect is that the distance between his brain and his heart is so great it’s nearly Shakespearean. (Think “Henry IV,” Part 1.) The less kind interpretation is that he’s a phony.
Both John Kasich and Marco Rubio have unremarkable accents and conversational styles. There’s little to cringe at.
Having handicapped our options in a highly subjective way, I’d urge you to ponder, tweak and vote accordingly. There are stupider ways to evaluate a candidate — as every primary has proved.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.