During postgame interviews, when a professional athlete makes a bold move to thank God or even his “Lord and Savior Jesus Christ” for the day’s success, it doesn’t bother me a bit.
My reaction is “Good for you” or “Who knew?” and I wonder whether the religious folks on the losing team are also giving thanks. (If they’re for real, they will — eventually.)
Then the moment is quickly forgotten, because it’s just sports. It’s just entertainment.
But when such openly religious declarations come from the lips of politicians, am I the only evangelical Christian in America who cringes? I hope not, and I wish they wouldn’t.
Despite this campaign’s looniness — it’s like an endless “American Idol” audition — the process by which the world’s largest and oldest representative democracy chooses its leaders is not mere entertainment. It’s very serious. And so is genuine faith.
Keeping the two distinct, even where they overlap, is paramount, both to healthy politics and to healthy religion. But it seems increasingly important to certain voters to hear the buzzwords and catchphrases that will reassure them, “He’s one of us.”
If I am “one of them,” so to speak, and I wince when candidates trumpet their faith a little too readily, how much more turned off must nonbelievers be?
When Marco Rubio took the podium early on Iowa caucus night and thanked his “Lord and Savior Jesus Christ,” I did a double take — and not because he had finished only third.
Some time later, Ted Cruz stepped forward to claim his victory and exclaimed, “To God be the glory!”
Hopefully he’ll understand some of us aren’t sure whether a caucus win in Iowa actually glorifies the omnipotent architect of the universe.
The problem for the Republican Party is that this is mainly a problem of the Republican Party.
It has long been noted that the religious polarization of modern American politics began with the Supreme Court’s regrettably sweeping Roe v. Wade decision. It swept many religious people right into the GOP, where an anti-abortion plank is always part of the platform.
Democrats, by contrast, would not allow the late Pennsylvania Gov. Robert Casey to speak at the 1992 convention because of his pro-life views.
Millennials, born post-Roe, have known only a world in which religiosity is associated with the right wing, and the close affiliation seems to be prompting increasing numbers of them to shun both.
Thus the problem for the GOP. The candidate who has been most mindful of appealing beyond the base is Mr. Rubio, which made his forthright declaration last Monday night all the more startling.
The reason I don’t worry when athletes give Jesus a shoutout is that there’s no inherent manipulation underway. Whether their words are genuine “bearing witness” or Pharisaical chest-thumping may be in the eye of the beholder, but the athlete isn’t after my vote or my money.
Politicians, however, are definitely after both. The potential for their religious declarations — like all their utterances — to be insincere is enormous.
Precisely because I take my faith so seriously, I prefer a candidate who is reluctant to talk about his, even when directly asked. Whatever is said, he’d better walk his talk.
That’s why Sen. Ted Cruz’s dirty tactics and lack of charitable giving are fair game: Having flaunted his faith, he oughtn’t be baldly flouting it.
By these standards, Hillary Clinton’s Methodism is low-key enough that religion in general doesn’t take much of a hit from her money-grubbing and dishonesty.
We could go on through the list of candidates, evaluating their characters and good works, but the greater challenge is to have a necessary and nuanced conversation about religion and politics — about how faith shapes our politics as individuals and as a nation.
When President Barack Obama touts his immigration and refugee policies as fulfilling our obligation to help the less fortunate — especially widows and orphans — he’s making a specifically biblical appeal.
Not everyone espouses a specific religion, but everyone has a world view. What we believe about human nature, a moral order, how to achieve and preserve a just and free society — these beliefs draw us to embrace particular policies and political structures.
The American experiment has always been about ensuring and exercising our “unalienable rights” — rights that flow from “the Creator” but that allow us all to pursue happiness as we see fit.
The candidate who can articulate this — authentically, with neither hypocrisy nor smarmy calculation — is the one who will have my vote.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.