Superstar statistician Nate Silver — the man who called 49 of the 50 states correctly in the 2012 election — wonders just what the heck is going on with the Republican Party.

Since Donald Trump is ideologically unreliable, not conventionally qualified and “extremely unpopular with general-election voters,” Mr. Silver had assumed the GOP would “muster whatever strength it had to try to stop” the real estate billionaire.

Instead, he writes on his fivethirtyeight.com blog, the party elite seems to be targeting Ted Cruz. What’s going on?

In this Year of the Protest Voter, you could reasonably ask that question about both parties, as their respective “establishments” watch the anointed candidates stumble and stall.

Advertise with us

On the Democrats’ side, socialist Bernie Sanders is surging ahead of front-runner Hillary Clinton in Iowa and New Hampshire. Observers point out that his rise coincides with receding concern over national security issues — implying, alas, that Democratic voters perceive this, for Ms. Clinton, as an area of integrity and success.

But it’s easy to see why the Dems don’t interfere as their two front-runners duke it out. Either one would carry forward Barack Obama’s leftist agenda and either one, in early-primary state polling, handily beats Mr. Trump.

So the big mystery is the GOP race, where a still-crowded field is a bonanza for drama-hungry media consumers and number-crunchers like Mr. Silver.

Mr. Silver asks why hasn’t “the Establishment” targeted faux-Republican Donald Trump? Why are some GOP leaders instead gearing up to hobble Ted Cruz?

“It may be that Republicans think of Cruz as the more immediate threat,” Mr. Silver writes, and once having removed Mr. Cruz, “then plan to turn around and attack Trump” later in the primaries — “a high-degree-of-difficulty caper to pull off.”

Advertise with us

Yes, it would be — especially for a party leadership that comes across as sluggish and inept.

But what Mr. Silver leaves unsaid is why Republican leaders might perceive Mr. Cruz that way — as the greater “threat.”

It’s true, many don’t like him. He helped orchestrate the widely unpopular 2013 government shutdown. (Hard-liners say it was the right thing to do. Cynics would argue it was the first big move in his presidential campaign.)

Mr. Cruz galvanized House Republicans to push Speaker John Boehner to the right, torpedoing victory or even compromise. When a state GOP leader asked Mr. Boehner about Mr. Cruz at a fundraiser in Texas, Mr. Cruz’s home, Mr. Boehner’s delayed but first response was simply to raise his middle finger.

Why would Republican elites target Ted Cruz? Because in the long run, the real Republican — not the fake one — is more damaging to the GOP “brand.” By no means is Mr. Trump either a conservative or a libertarian. Everybody knows this. With his snarling bombast, he is every Democrat cartoonist’s caricature of a Republican, but he is sui generis — one of a kind. So when his time in the political limelight ends, the damage to the GOP “brand” will be short-lived — little more than a freakish asterisk in party history.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Cruz is a different animal altogether. The Donald is a “wink, wink” Republican, but not the senator. He’s the real thing, albeit a mean, even brutal, manifestation.

He has risen quickly through the ranks, having moved from the Ivy League to a U.S. Supreme Court clerkship, to Texas solicitor general to the Senate — with more plum posts in between.

He’s a Baptist minister’s son who doesn’t hesitate to draw primary workers into a “prayer circle” on a campaign stop. His biggest super-PAC is now led by David Barton, a self-made evangelical leader in the “Christian nation” movement whose ironically titled history book, “The Jefferson Lies,” has been thoroughly debunked.

If Mr. Cruz’s faith is real, he should be concerned about the use of false history, bad theology and fear-mongering to galvanize his base. If he doesn’t himself believe the Christian nation nonsense, he would have a hard time pivoting from his current all-in posture to make a broader, more inclusive appeal during the general election.

That more inclusive, liberty-embracing approach is, by the way, the real evangelical heritage: From Roger Williams to the “Danbury Baptists,” his forebears and mine made common cause with non-believers — especially that great skeptic Thomas Jefferson — to establish freedom of religion.

Advertise with us

It also happens to be the only approach that can win. That’s why the GOP establishment has to attack the threat Mr. Cruz embodies. I say Godspeed.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com