Each year’s Advent services give my husband the opportunity to remind me how much he dislikes the carol “In the Bleak Midwinter.”
He relishes telling me this and then demonstrating why, droning like a grade-school clarinet: “Snow was falling, snow on snow, sno-ow o-on snow,” he whines — and I join him, an octave higher, to vent my general Christmastime discontent.
I’m not a big fan of Christmas, and not just because of the insipid music or the exhausting preparations.
This year, so far, we’ve escaped the dreaded “Bleak Midwinter” carol but rediscovered another old one, “It Came Upon a Midnight Clear.” It doesn’t rank much better on the sap-o-meter, really, but its final verse happens to contain this gorgeous lyric:
For lo! the days are hastening on…
When peace shall over all the earth
Its ancient splendors fling…
What an image! Peace, not an “it” but in my mind a noble beauty like Justice, and instead of holding scales aloft as though to summon us to attention, she flings — flings! — a blanket of calm over our cities and plains.
Justice snaps our spines upright, Peace bids us rest in her lavish embrace.
And peace does seem “ancient” — long ago and far away. As another year of corrosive unrest draws to a close, a season of peace would be most welcome. But if Christmas itself is a silent night, the run-up to it is brash discord. The annual so-called “war” is dispiriting.
The materialism of Christmas has long been decried. My Depression-baby parents remember poverty so deep that getting some candy and an orange was considered a truly blessed Noel. If my mother occasionally received a new doll or toy, it was because she was lucky enough to have a wealthy, childless great-aunt.
The transition from simple, spiritual observance to orgy of acquisition happened in my lifetime. In post-war prosperity, our deprived parents were happy to give us baby boomers everything they’d never had.
Chatty Cathys, Barbies and G.I. Joes with all the accessories. Paint sets and puzzles and BB guns.
I’m sure the gift my parents most regret was the child-sized drum set they bought my brother when he was 8 or 9 years old. There was no silent night, no flinging of peace at our house — not for many weeks, until Brian finally flailed the worn snare drum so hard he punctured its head. It was not replaced.
For years now, religious folk have been striving to return quiet, simplicity and meaning to Christmas. “Jesus is the reason for the season,” the slogan goes.
Well, yes, for some of us he is. In fact, for most of us he is. Despite the growing ranks of the unaffiliated, more than 70 percent of Americans still identify themselves as Christians.
But that also means up to 30 percent of any merchant’s potential customers are not Christians and may prefer, consciously or unconsciously, a nonsectarian approach as they join the holiday hordes at the mall.
“Merry Christmas” or “Season’s Greetings”? The merchant gets to choose how inclusive to make his marketing, and Christians ought to consider that a marketing decision is not necessarily a religious assault.
While reasserting the origins and religious significance of a nationwide government holiday is not illogical, logic doesn’t make the assertion … winsome.
Christians live under a mandate to share our faith with others, but we aren’t fulfilling the “great commandment” very ably when we use that faith not for blessing others but for battling them.
If we believe that the God of the universe would come to earth as a baby, to live, die and rise again to redeem and repair his creation, why do we need that faith affirmed by a Starbucks coffee cup?
Isn’t Jesus bigger than that?
When we denounce or strike back at every perceived provocation, we demean the good news we’re supposed to be celebrating. We make it sour and petty, rather than transformative and grand.
“When peace shall over all the earth / Its ancient splendors fling…”
When will we see the ancient splendors of peace? The carol’s “prophet bards” predict some great day still to come, but right here and now, we could all stand a little more flinging of peace.
The one whose birth so many of us celebrate was very pointedly not about pushback and putdowns, but love. Maybe the best way to celebrate him is to emulate him.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.