Cynics of any political persuasion should have a fun new parlor game just in time for the holiday parties: Which pillar of Democratic Party history will be the next to fall?
Last year it was Andrew Jackson, when the Stanford University staging of a controversial rock musical about him was canceled in response to student protests. This year it is Princeton University and Woodrow Wilson.
December was usually an auspicious month for Wilson. His birth (1856), the second of his two happy marriages (1915) and his winning the Nobel Peace Prize (1920) all happened in December.
But December 2015 is shaping up as something altogether different. Wilson’s political descendants, Progressive Democrats, are suddenly weighing him and finding him wanting — so much so that they demand he be expunged from history.
They have to, of course. The purging process is virtually encoded in progressives’ DNA.
The uproar began last month, when student activists held a 32-hour sit-in to draw attention to what they believe is the long-ago Princeton president’s racist legacy. (After a decade or so at the Ivy League institution, Wilson served briefly as governor of New Jersey, taking advantage of a divided Republican Party and three-way race to vault to the White House.)
Now begins the dismantling of his legacy — whatever it actually is. Newspapers and websites have been awash in essays and editorials urging Princeton to move in this direction or that, depending on each writer’s take on a history that is more nuanced (of course) than activists assert.
Although I have no desire to defend a Progressive Democrat, and particularly not Wilson, I do feel compelled to note the complexities of his history, because the unfolding, un-nuanced drama is yet another example of modern liberalism’s need to devour its own.
That’s what happens when you seek personal redemption through politics. Whether Puritan, Progressive or Marxist, if you believe in the inevitable ascent of homo sapiens — or his ultimate perfectibility through the force of law or a good five-year plan or the EPA — you have tied yourself to a narrative in which this progress must be regularly demonstrated.
In which you must regularly demonstrate your progress.
In its youth, each generation proves its superior piety and purity by feasting on the ideological carcasses of yesterday — like Woodrow Wilson, the Ur-Progressive. They do not pause to consider what blind spots or outright animuses of their own will be decried in years to come. They only know that they are right, right now. They must be.
This is the mindset of adolescents. It’s why Winston Churchill and others could quip, “If you’re a conservative at 20 you have no heart, and if you’re a liberal at 40 you have no brain.”
So the ruckuses at America’s college campuses — populated by the young (students) and those lacking real-world experience (many of their professors) — should come as no shock, really. The surprise is when older folk fail to respond with more wisdom.
We all know that many of our most illustrious forebears were slaveholders — including venerated founders such as Washington, Jefferson, Franklin, Madison and Monroe.
Some who never owned slaves expressed mildly racist viewpoints in their private correspondence, but you won’t see Republicans disavowing, say, Abraham Lincoln any time soon.
Conservatives — no matter what their party affiliation, if any — have as their philosophical starting point an understanding of the human condition as tragically flawed and, unfortunately, not as malleable and improvable as we all might like.
In fact, how anyone can survey the last 100 years of world history and not believe in the concept of original sin is completely beyond me.
But whatever our doctrines or dogmas, “hope for the best, prepare for the worst” is built into our constitutional system, our checks and balances, our government of laws. When presented with a ghost of America Past — in the sweep of a mural, in bronze on a pedestal — we should expect to see imperfections.
Should we feel oppressed or offended by those imperfections? Should we banish the bearers of those flaws? Only if the imperfections are truly monstrous, or unrelieved by redeeming qualities.
If we’re wise, we’ll consider former paragons with an eye to our own as-yet-unrecognized errors.
But that’s not as easy and immediately satisfying as dethroning the dead. And progressives who must display progress will soon have to find a new target.
I’ve got no skin in this game, but if I did, I’d be rooting against racial eugenecist Margaret Sanger.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.