With the number of dead from the Paris terrorist attacks still rising and the security of the free world at stake, you’d think America’s leaders could restrain their partisan advantage-seeking long enough to conduct a sober conversation about the Syrian refugee crisis.
Instead, we’ve been treated to more empty-headed posturing than appears in a typical issue of Vogue.
There have been some voices of reason, but they are lost in the passel of politicians and pundits, both national and local, who would use a still-unfolding tragedy to tout their supposed compassion and denounce their opponents’ lack thereof (the Democrats), or to flex their national security muscles and appeal to xenophobes and anti-immigrationists (the Republicans).
The most deplorable development, though, is some of these leaders’ moral bullying of ordinary Americans.
The first leader to denounce the “political posturing” was President Barack Obama, who used the international platform of the G-20 conference to criticize those who dared to disagree with his decision to admit 10,000 Syrian refugees into the U.S.
When MSNBC host Chris “Thrill Up My Leg” Matthews rebukes the president for snarkiness, chances are the president has indeed gone too far.
At the other end of the spectrum are the extremists — mostly right wing — who reject all refugees categorically or propose a religious test for their admission.
Should the U.S. have been making a special effort to accept persecuted Christians fleeing the Middle East for the past decade? Yes, especially since the Iraq War did so much to worsen their plight.
But our failure to do enough then doesn’t justify a religious test for immigrants now. On this the president is right — although he has been disastrously wrong on his Syria policies and must shoulder considerable responsibility for the current crisis.
A more intensive and better informed screening process should be able to separate the peaceful from the dangerous without resorting to religious tests. But four years into the Syrian refugee crisis, our own intelligence community says we are still not prepared to do this.
We’ve known since Sept. 11, 2001, that determined terrorists will exploit our hospitality and incompetent immigration bureaucracy to kill and destroy.
France knows this now, too: A suicide bomber’s fake Syrian passport was found near his body at the Paris soccer stadium.
But we are still not ready. Way back in February, our counterterrorism officials were calling the Syrian refugees a “population of concern” and telling the House Homeland Security Committee that potential terrorists could be hiding among them.
If those charged with improving our national security admit — to their own embarrassment — that our security systems are still not adequate, shouldn’t we heed their warning?
Should the president, a governor or a mayor second-guess them?
Most of us embrace our nation’s historic role as a haven for the oppressed, but we see no reason to be stupid about it.
Insisting on better screening — and halting the influx until it’s in place — is not a failure of compassion. After all, where’s the compassion in recklessly exposing innocent American civilians to those the FBI has deemed potential terrorists?
The talk-show host who lives in a Manhattan high-rise or posh Pittsburgh suburb probably doesn’t have to worry about a jihadi moving in next door. Ditto for the governor in his well-guarded mansion.
Here’s another thing we ordinary people know, and by ordinary I mean vulnerable: The terrorists are not trying to create a climate of “fear and hysteria.” That is not their objective. This is: They are trying to kill as many of us as they can. Their successes in that atrocious endeavor are the cause of our fear.
Our fear is not hysterical. It is completely rational. Rhetoric that asserts the contrary is not only illogical, it is bullying. We should not allow ourselves to be bullied into accepting unreasonable risk.
And now — when it matters very much — the U.S. House has acted in a sober, bipartisan way, voting, 289-137, to suspend the president’s refugee program and to intensify the screening process. The pro votes include 47 of 188 House Democrats (none of them from Pennsylvania, alas).
One can only hope a similar bill will garner enough Senate support to withstand the president’s veto.
This action buys us time — time to protect ourselves, not against 3-year-old orphans, as a sneering Mr. Obama suggested, but against hidden jihadis, as a reeling Paris proves we must.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.