Unless someone in our inner circle of friends and family is directly affected by mental illness, most of us don’t pay much attention to how society handles it.
That is, until another mass shooting somewhere tragically forces the issue front and center.
Then, for a few days, we feverishly discuss involuntary treatment and privacy laws and background checks for gun buyers — before returning to life as normal.
Not so Tim Murphy. The congressman, a Republican from Upper St. Clair, has made reform of our nation’s mental health care system his tireless focus for almost three years.
It’s a natural outgrowth of his career as a child psychologist and his ongoing service treating veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder at the Naval Hospital in Bethesda, Md.
Progress is suddenly at hand in Congress, and last week brought more endorsements for the “Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act” from newspaper editorial boards — more than 40 now — whose ideological leanings range “all across the spectrum,” he said in a phone interview Friday.
What galvanized Mr. Murphy’s crusade was the horrific Newtown, Conn., massacre of Dec. 14, 2012, when an obviously disturbed 20-year-old named Adam Lanza killed 27 people, 20 of them first-graders at Sandy Hook Elementary School.
This is not to say that all mass murderers are mentally ill, or that all people afflicted with mental disease are potentially violent — not at all.
But approximately 10 million Americans struggle with serious mental illness, including severe depression, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. The illness may result in suicide, drug abuse, crime, homelessness — the list of sorrows is long.
Our failure to care for those who are ill comes at a high cost — not just in economic terms, but also in wasted human potential and, occasionally, terrible violence.
Mental illness is a disease, not a character flaw. We do not treat people with cancer or diabetes so callously.
To demand change, it should be enough to know the three biggest “hospitals” in our national mental health care system are actually jails — in New York City, Chicago and Los Angeles.
For three years, Mr. Murphy has been slogging away to turn H.R. 2646 into law. Among other changes, the bill would slightly ease the flow of information among approved caregivers and increase money to states that take a more proactive approach to care.
A couple of significant obstacles to reform remain.
Patient-rights advocates oppose allowing mental health professionals to share a patient’s information — such as diagnoses, medications and treatment plans — with “an identified responsible caregiver,” such as the parent of a troubled young adult.
They also oppose increased use of “assisted outpatient treatment,” an involuntary assignment to outpatient care, something that officers of the court in 46 states can already do.
These advocates “are fighting for [patients’] right to be sick,” Mr. Murphy said, “and we’re fighting for their right to be well.
“They say they are protecting the rights of the mentally ill, but you have no rights in jail, you have no rights if you’re tied to a hospital bed, you have no rights in a morgue.”
The standard for mandated care should no longer be the centuries-old “imminent danger” to oneself or to others. Why let things deteriorate to a bleaker level? Why wait for another Newtown?
“I ask [the skeptical], ‘Do you think Adam Lanza should have been involuntarily committed?’ If they say no,” Mr. Murphy says, “then there’s nothing else to discuss.”
Recent studies demonstrate that more proactive treatment improves most quality-of-life indicators for a strong majority of patients, reduces incarceration rates and also cuts costs by a whopping 50 percent.
A big step approaches in November, when the Energy and Commerce subcommittee may finally “mark up” the bill — reviewing it line by line to prep it for the full committee, to go on to the full House.
The bill’s list of sponsors keeps growing, too — 149 now, including 40-some Democrats.
For some, Mr. Murphy says, the light goes on due to personal loss: A colleague signed on after a close friend’s wife committed suicide.
For others, it is the accumulation of national tragedies — what he calls “the bloody summer of 2015.”
For every mass shooting, he said, Congress observes a moment of silence. After the slaying of 10 earlier this month at an Oregon community college, Mr. Murphy avoided the House chamber, because he knew he would probably lose his composure.
Someone else did that, he later learned: A colleague pierced the quiet by shouting, “Let’s do something!”
“He’s right,” Mr. Murphy says. “I'm not going to let this go."
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.