A small tin of breath mints at the checkout counter of a posh suburban store caught my eye.

It featured 2008’s red-and-blue campaign image of President Barack Obama, but the words were a bit different. “This is change?” read the tin of “Disappoint Mints.”

This isn’t being marketed to Republicans: They wouldn’t cry if hope and change went splat, right?

These mints are an endlessly adaptable product, since disappointment is a bipartisan constant of politics.

Advertise with us

Despite my different political philosophy, I’d still hoped Mr. Obama’s first election augured a change in the nation’s mood — an end to the bitterness, a return to the post-9/​11 feeling of pulling together rather than apart.

That hasn’t happened.

“When did politics become so polarized?” I asked that question two weeks ago, then largely sidestepped it — partly because it would have shifted that column’s focus and partly because I thought I’d covered it recently enough.

But the 18 months since that prior coverage is an eon in media time, and the millennials and their younger siblings have known nothing but the modern era’s nonstop bile. If we asked what got us here, could we change course?

Even a casual reader of history knows democracy has always featured nasty campaigns with mud-slinging, rumor and slander. But there once was more of a difference between what the political class does for a living and the way the rest of us live.

Advertise with us

As citizens, we pursued our political differences right up to where we shared adversity — the Depression, the world wars — that brought us together. There was space to put politics aside and be countrymen. That’s not the norm now.

When did the public’s polarization begin? There’s no bright line, but through some fascinating back-and-forth with readers over the years, I’ve narrowed it down to either the McCarthy hearings of the early 1950s or Lyndon Johnson’s daisy picking-mushroom cloud takedown of Barry Goldwater in 1964.

I lean toward the latter. Here’s why: Though Sen. Joe McCarthy was a Republican, he enjoyed strong support from many anti-Communist Democrats, including the Kennedy family, and Senate Democrats and Republicans joined forces to take him down.

So McCarthy blurred party lines rather than simply alienating one side from the other. Not so Johnson’s ad.

While these two landmark events share in common the evolving power of modern broadcast media, they differ in a crucial way. When televised hearings crippled Sen. McCarthy, it was a case of the medium’s power punishing someone who had damaged so many others.

Advertise with us

But President Johnson’s attack on Sen. Goldwater? Undeserved in its meanness, the new medium was doing only harm, not justice.

Fifteen years of enormous social upheaval followed, increasingly seen live from our dinner tables each night. Watergate didn’t feel polarizing in the current way, since most people seemed to agree that Richard Nixon earned his downfall and were thus equally disappointed by the whole mess.

No, our partisan polarization didn’t really pick up steam until the 1980s. Ronald Reagan’s two landslide victories realigned the political landscape, and his “Teflon” quality allowed him to weather the Iran-Contra hearings unscathed.

It’s hard not to see left-wing fury animating the virulent attacks on Supreme Court nominees Robert Bork in 1987 and Clarence Thomas in 1991, both selected by Republican presidents and neither man deserving of the ensuing viciousness.

And it’s hard not to see right-wing payback in the rabid pursuit of every possible scandal against President Bill Clinton, up to and including impeachment.

Advertise with us

As the mood has gotten angrier, the two parties have moved farther and farther apart, with both the breach and the mood exacerbated by modern media — both by the technologies themselves and by the people who control them.

Left-wing media bias was thoroughly researched in the 1980s; read “The Media Elite” for a walk down memory lane. And if one side sees it is never getting a fair shake from the nation’s information gatekeepers, then why wouldn’t it look for other media — talk radio, cable news — to get its version of facts out?

Today, we are even more fractured, our conflicts amplified beyond measure by new social media.

This situation just isn’t working for us, for democracy. We can’t go back, so how do we go forward — without the incessant, angry clatter?

The only possibilities I see are “the soft answer [that] turns away wrath,” a healthy skepticism for the distorting effects of all media — and political candidates whose presence and thinking radiate calm, not egotism or cool.

Advertise with us

I’m still hoping for change.

Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com.