Two admirable men have just passed on and off the American stage.
Pope Francis came to the U.S. — had you heard? — and John Boehner resigned as speaker of the House, just one day after the pope became the first pontiff to address Congress.
Pope Francis arrived in triumph, while the speaker left in some measure of failure.
News coverage of these events focused heavily on our country’s divisions, implying a need for unity and peace. This was true even before the pope’s United Nations appearance made a call for peace explicit. Why?
Why are our society’s polarized disagreements on serious topics the primary concern in both the pope and Boehner news narratives?
Coverage of the pope’s visit was glowing, even breathless. And it wasn’t just that those network types love a parade: big crowds + banners + blessings for babies = ratings!
No, the mainstream media’s relief runs deeper than that. They’ve finally found a Christian they don’t despise.
They like Pope Francis not just because of his warmth and endearing modesty. It’s also because his teachings seem, at first glance, and second, to fit the media’s indisputable leftist inclinations.
“Pope Francis Arrives in U.S., Faces a Polarized Country” — this was the common headline on a widely carried Associated Press story that mirrored the coverage overall.
The article reviewed the pontiff’s teachings on poverty, immigration, same-sex marriage and more, noting that these have often antagonized “Republicans and many conservative Catholics.”
Try to imagine a similar reception for a Protestant leader. You can’t, but that’s mostly by design, of course. Although we Protestants outnumber Catholics in America by 2-to-1, we have no single leader.
But when a Billy Graham or a Jerry Falwell has ventured into political territory, the media response has been sour and disapproving. Maybe that’s because the Protestants tend to wear drab business suits and eschew parades, but I’m guessing it has more to do with the evangelicals’ conservative-leaning positions, which antagonize, oh, Democrats and liberal Catholics.
Similarly, the weekend’s big political story netted this headline, among others — “Boehner’s Departure: ‘A Victory for Dysfunction.’ ”
The article itself includes different perspectives on why the speaker left and what path he had forged as Republican leader. But it was a Democrat’s take — Rep. Steny Hoyer’s — showcased in the headline.
His viewpoint shaped the article, in fact: He and others described Mr. Boehner as a “true gentleman” who “wanted this institution to work.” Alas.
But whether you think Congress “works” or not depends on what you want it to achieve.
Sane, mature people desire to live in peace. But sane, mature people also recognize this isn’t possible. So we pick our battles, as the saying goes. Wisdom also requires that we ponder who started the battle and who’s calling on whom to end it.
Congress has always battled, but when did politics become so polarized? The historical record indicates things took a stark turn for the worse when the Obama administration forced through the transformative “Affordable Care Act” without bipartisan support.
That led directly to a new and growing Republican majority, which President Barack Obama increasingly circumvents with executive orders and memos.
Though I don’t agree with government shutdowns, Congress does have the less disruptive power to refuse to fund executive orders. Under Mr. Boehner, this resistance was not offered, so intraparty conflicts were necessary to preserve some balance of powers. That is Congress “working.”
(You could argue Congress grew polarized during the Iraq War, too, but back then the media were not urging peace and unity.)
When the leader of the Roman Catholic Church visits the United Nations and calls for peace, what does it mean? The West cannot lie down for global jihad or tyrants with nuclear arms.
When the pope urges us to embrace immigrants, he’ll have this daughter of immigrants’ concurrence when he’s also urging immigrants to enter legally.
When Pope Francis decries the “idolatry of money,” he wins my heart. But when he claims “unbridled capitalism” has impoverished the world, he is flat-out wrong. Even Marxist paradises have embraced capitalism and finally prospered.
While capitalism occasionally needs “bridling,” better it be done through the pulpit’s persuasion than government regulation.
While the church can accommodate an unlimited number of newcomers, the state cannot.
Bottom line — there’s a difference between what church and state can accomplish. But that distinction will be actively ignored in certain political enclaves.
Whether we disagree on the means or the ends, our conflicts must continue. Beware the call for peace. From some it is genuine. From some it means, “Please capitulate.”
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.