In response to an email alert that a seventh video on the organ-harvesting of aborted fetuses had been released, I did what the rest of America is apparently doing:
I spent five hours working in my garden. I answered lots of email. Then I went to a baseball game.
I did everything except watch the video because, having seen the first few in this series, I already knew the latest one would be upsetting, even gruesome.
It would remove the possibility of pretending, on a lovely late-summer day, that all is right with the world. And all I want, during these waning summer days, is a respite from life’s difficulties and sadness.
You too? If so — if you intentionally avoided watching a video that includes a young woman describing how she was instructed to harvest the brain from an aborted but intact baby boy — then you and I actually belong to a surprisingly small minority.
Most Americans (70 percent) are not watching these videos simply because they are barely aware the videos exist, according to a YouGov poll. But of those who are aware, more than half are nonetheless declining to watch (as I was this week) — perhaps to avoid the heartsick feeling that comes with knowledge.
Both situations — ignorance and avoidance — could spring from the fact that the videos confront the nation’s conscience right at the intersection of professional bias and personal discomfort.
The videos reveal Planned Parenthood officials and business partners discussing surgical techniques and negotiating fees to procure the organs and tissues of aborted fetuses. The videos were produced by the Center for Medical Progress, a nonprofit group of “citizen journalists dedicated to monitoring and reporting on medical ethics.”
Plenty of what they’ve uncovered is very troubling, some of it clearly illegal and all of it profoundly inhumane.
Though conservative publications and websites are sending out regular updates, mainstream media have maintained relative silence on the topic.
The right-wing Media Research Center monitored television coverage and found that three weeks after the first shocking video’s release, the three major networks together had spent only 20 minutes on the story, while spending almost 93 minutes in just two weeks on Cecil the Lion.
The New York Times ignored last week’s video release and has generated relatively little on the matter besides negative editorials. One decries the journalistic practices — false identities, hidden cameras — sometimes used to obtain footage. It makes you wonder how they’ve countenanced “60 Minutes” all these years.
The same Times editorial labels this “video campaign” a “deception,” but last summer, the Times did its own video campaign — posting a very laudatory documentary excerpt on the Dutch doctor who created an “abortion ship” to operate off the coast of countries where it is illegal.
The Times carries “all the news that’s fit to print”? No, all the news that fits their squint.
Anti-abortion activists should ignore the question of whether fetal tissues are being “sold” (a “gray area,” intones the Times) and focus on what makes all of us — from the bilious Times staff to the anonymous YouGov survey respondents — deeply uncomfortable: That these aborted fetuses are developed enough to have brains, hearts and livers worth harvesting.
That they are human, and we have stooped to benefiting from their dead bodies.
The phrase “slippery slope” is overused, but it truly applies to our nation’s decades-long debate: We’ve slid ever downward, from legalizing abortion to allowing fetal tissue research, to now countenancing the delivering of living fetuses that are killed ex utero to harvest bigger organs.
Former “procurement technician” Holly O’Donnell stood at the edge of the slope and turned back.
After describing in the latest video a shattering incident, she decided: “Even if that could have been the cure for some kind of disease … I still wish I wouldn’t have done it. I don’t want to be that person.”
After what she saw — and did — she had to quit.
Likewise, I don’t think the 47 percent of the American people who are pro-abortion rights ever wished for these atrocities to be committed under the banner of freedom or progress. Surely, they would not condone this, if they knew.
That’s why it’s so important to certain people and organizations to mock and quash the videos — and why it’s so important for us to see them.
We cannot bury our heads in summer’s wishful escapism. All is not right with the world, and we have to look.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.