Someone wise once warned, “Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.”
Someone else amended this years later by pointing out that actually, eternal vigilance is the price of everything.
It’s certainly the price we pay to make our physical surroundings beautiful. Ask anyone who owns a piece of land. The battle is either Mother Nature (weeds) or human nature (litter).
Speaking of litter, billboards are my bete noire, but let’s return to that vigilance-is-the-price-of-everything insight:
“There will always be people who oppose whatever you hold dear,” wrote scientist Steven Dutch in “Dutch’s Laws of Just About Everything.”
“They will try to overturn, evade or weaken your reforms. Others will seek power, wealth, or status without doing any work. The only way to keep what you have is to guard it constantly.”
Thank goodness Monroeville residents did. The story is 7 months old, but it’s fresh encouragement to Pittsburghers worried about the decaying Bayer sign.
The one constant in Monroeville’s latest battle and Pittsburgh’s unfolding one is Mike Dawida. The former county commissioner and state senator brings to his nonprofit work at Scenic Pittsburgh a great understanding of the long slog.
But even he was surprised when Monroeville government again faced a New Jersey-based company’s request to place enormous, two-sided digital billboards along the Parkway East.
“Seven years ago, the community rose up in great anger and overwhelmingly smacked it down,” Mr. Dawida said. “How could they have forgotten?”
With a high turnover, few municipal council members were around to remember, but residents sure did.
Paul Caliari, a councilman for only two years, told me constituents from every ward crowded January’s hearing, including homeowners worried about losing their woodland view. There was, he said, “zero support” for the signs.
Mr. Dawida said people were “stunned” when his “right-hand man Dave Demko pointed out they’d get almost no revenue from the billboards.” Typically, a municipality gets about $100 per year per sign, “and once you put them in, they’re there forever.”
Like the former Bayer sign.
Talks between city officials and Lamar Advertising, which owns the sign, disintegrated a couple of months ago. Scenic Pittsburgh would like to help all parties craft a win-win solution.
“We think there are several alternatives,” Mr. Dawida said. “We need the help of a company” — one like Bayer, which “always used it as a public service.”
“Or Lamar could donate it — maybe to our nonprofit — they can get tax benefits from that — and we’d make it into an extension of [Mount Washington’s] greenway park. Or maybe it could become something akin to the Hollywood sign …
“We are hoping Lamar shows community spirit, but they haven’t returned any of our calls or letters.”
They didn’t respond to my questions Friday either. My fear is that Lamar will leverage the Bayer sign to install more flashing digital billboards elsewhere.
At Monroeville’s January hearing, an Interstate Outdoor Advertising expert testified digital billboards are “not in the realm of being a traffic hazard” because drivers barely look at them.
Then why have them?
But don’t just trust your own logic: An Israeli study compared traffic accidents on a Tel Aviv highway in 2007 when large digital billboards were present, with accidents in 2008 after a court ordered the signs removed or covered. Accidents fell by one-third, and crashes with injuries or fatalities fell by two-thirds.
Add such evidence to what we know of cell phones, and you have to tremble for our young drivers. It would be a proverbial deal with the devil to trade safety for beauty.
But something has to change on the face of Mount Washington. And many of the region’s oodles of municipalities need to contact Scenic Pittsburgh to tighten up their sign ordinances — before it’s too late.
Billboards enjoy certain protections as a form of free speech, but Mr. Dawida finds them “inherently ugly” and asserts, “Beauty is good for business.”
Amen to that. Recovering Pittsburgh’s natural beauty has been great for our prosperity.
But eternal vigilance is required — vigilance and maybe some clever maneuvering.
Back at that January hearing, “they told me I wasn’t allowed to speak because I wasn’t from Monroeville, even though for the past four hours, the New Jersey people” had been weighing in.
“So a community member handed me a dollar and said, ‘Mr. Dawida is my attorney.’ ”
He got five minutes. Here’s hoping he — and we — are just as effective sermonizing on the Mount.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.