If you were worried that a pair of controversial “sting” videos portrayed you as cold and callous, would you remove all doubt with a smug, aggressive tweet?
That’s what Planned Parenthood did Friday on Twitter, calling their philosophical opponents “anti-abortion minions” and using an animated “Minions” movie clip that shows the yellow minion delivering a “mic drop.”
I’m almost as confused as Planned Parenthood’s public relations people obviously are: Isn’t a mic drop a display of triumph? So if a minion is dropping the mic, and pro-lifers are minions, isn’t Planned Parenthood’s tweet actually acknowledging that their adversaries just won a big round?
Because they did. The pro-life cause has made a significant step forward in its decades-long and increasingly successful battle for the conflicted hearts and minds of the American people.
For reasons that far transcend politics, we should all hope pro-life advocates don’t falter right now.
The Center for Medical Progress recently released two successive videos in which its “citizen journalists,” posing as biotech business representatives, secretly recorded Planned Parenthood executives discussing how they alter abortion techniques to obtain intact organs and tissues from more-developed “cases” and how much these specimens might cost their would-be clients.
Abortion rights advocates and their attorneys will be arguing for months over the exact meaning of the word “sale,” but common-sense Americans know a price negotiation when they see one.
They can see, highly edited though the videos are, that abortion providers casually discuss how to rotate a second-trimester fetus into a breech position in order to deliver and harvest intact organs.
They see this discussed over lunch with wine.
It is no stretch to say that people are repulsed. Though what’s repulsive may nonetheless be legal, the proof and the power of the public’s revulsion are evident in the high-profile response.
In the wake of the videos’ one-two punch, the left wing’s defensiveness and hairsplitting are to be expected — though the Obama administration’s decision to investigate only the tiny Center for Medical Progress and not the taxpayer-funded, billion-dollar Planned Parenthood is stunning. The only explanation is vengeance.
Proof of the damage to the pro-choice cause is in the responses of those who want to be perceived as neutral and centrist. Xerox, Coca-Cola and Ford Motor Co. have denied being donors to Planned Parenthood and requested that their names be removed from its official donor list.
Dozens more companies and nonprofits are distancing themselves from Planned Parenthood while explaining that they simply match employees’ donations to nonprofits — even those that “do not necessarily reflect” the company’s values.
Planned Parenthood attorney Roger Evans has pre-emptively warned that there are “thousands of hours of videotape” similar to what we’ve already seen. “Thousands of hours”? If so, this undermines the abortion provider’s claim that harvesting fetal tissue is not an important part of its clinics’ work.
And indeed, the Center for Medical Progress has posted a biotech company’s brochure, purportedly distributed to Planned Parenthood affiliates, that promises “financial benefit” and “fiscal growth” to the individual clinics it courts.
But tone-deafness isn’t a snare only to the pro-choice side. This is a crucial moment for pro-lifers to move decisively but gently, not exultantly or in angry self-righteousness.
After all, abortion is in every respect a tragedy. It is easy to lose sight of this and to get caught up in the political battle, at the expense of winning hearts, some of which may already be broken — by sad experience, not the damning videos.
Americans remain deeply conflicted over abortion, but an ever-growing majority of us describe ourselves as pro-life, and what we recoil from in these videos is the monetizing of death. We worry rightly that we’ve become a society indifferent to the dignity of human life.
Now is the moment to pass legislation that prohibits abortions after 20 weeks — at the latest — since a strong majority of Americans actually support a ban after the first trimester.
And now is the time to remove taxpayer support from abortion providers. Although Planned Parenthood’s defiant tweet claimed “anti-abortion minions want to bully us into silence,” that’s not what we minions want. We just don’t want to be party to the dismembering and organ-harvesting of unborn but sentient babies.
The videos make any false sense of ease impossible. The nation’s only appropriate response is a sorrowful refusal to help perpetuate this tragedy.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.